Which 7870 XT

Do I go for this: http://www.aria.co.uk/Products/Components/Graphics+Cards/AMD+Radeon/Radeon+HD+7870+Tahiti+LE/XFX+Double+D+Radeon+HD+7870+GHz+Edition+%28Tahiti+LE%29+OC+2GB+GDDR5+Graphics+Card+%5BFX-787A-CNAC%5D+%2B+4+FREE+GAMES%21+?productId=55140

Or: http://www.aria.co.uk/Products/Components/Graphics+Cards/AMD+Radeon/Radeon+HD+7870+Tahiti+LE/VTX3D+Black+Edition+Radeon+HD+7870+%28Tahiti+LE%29+OC+2GB+GDDR5+Graphics+Card+%5BVX7870+2GBD5-2DHV3E%5D+%2B+2+FREE+GAMES%21+?productId=53474 - I have the Card already but it's not working so I might get a refund or it fixed...

Which one do I go for?

XFX have a better eputation