The end of manjaro - the ugly divorce

Now I’m curious as to what drama and what incidents?? Perhaps I might have missed something???

sorry but this guy (as many others) don’t have any glue about manjaro and it’s deployment and are talking crap from the past. there are different branches / stages that you can run/choose from manjaro. you want to be on stable (hiding the packages a little bit) ? then go on stable. you wanna be actual ? then switch on testing. you wanna be a nerd with suicidal tendencies and like to update your system several times a day cause the newest stuff can’t be hot enough ? then switch to unstable. you’ve burned your fingers with unstable ? then switch back to stable or testing. i’ve never seen any distro out in the linux-universe that is even able to present such a functionality.

there is a lot of false / outdated information out in the web about manjaro and a guy like this manjaro-noob at youtube should be ashamed about the crap he’s talking and rtfm first.

setting manjaro to unstable-branch is 100% arch-nasty (and i like it)

2 Likes

Interesting that they can change forth and back (unlike Debian, where you only can change one way).

Does that work flawlessly IRL?

yes, absolut. used it several times, no problems.

1 Like

Ah well not the first time that we have seen Manjaro drama.
And it likely won´t be the last.

This is one of the reasons why i played around with Manjaro in the past.
And just due to drama totally lost interest in it.
I´d just stick to the bigger distro´s that are around for a very long time.
And not having to deal with all the drama.

3 Likes

+1 for archinstall

Protip; be sure to install the networking while installing arch, if you like having internet.

I did one install and forgot to install the networking and could not connect to wifi or ethernet, as there was no network manager. And I couldn’t install the network manager from the package manager due to the lack of internet. Chicken or egg.

Perhaps there is a way to downloading the package from another machine and install via USB, but I simply reinstalled making sure to dig through each menu and read carefully…

:facepalm:

4 Likes

which distros are bigger if you’re heading to an arch-based one ? cachy-os is a very young distro, no one can predict if this distro gets established in the future. it’s a community-driven distro with a lot of motivated maintainers, but who guarantees that these motivated people stay on the project ? we’ve seen it in the past that such distros get popular and disappear after some time due to several reasons. i would not bet on cachy’s future. endeavour is more established but has a similar history. can anyone remember antergos and its history ? arch itself ? i wanna use an os in the first place, arch is nice if you wanna play around but to be productive is something else.

manjaro is established for more than a decade now and i couldn’t believe that turmoil now.

nevertheless, there will be no further news until the ‘rebels of the mutiny’ founded their e.V. it seems that the update-support is still active ( i received updates at the stable and unstable branch) and will use manjaro while preparing to a switch in case that manjaro’s future gets weired. i doubt that manjaro has a reliable future if they turn it in this e.V. but that’s my personal impression.

let’s see what happens in the upcoming weeks/months.

1 Like

Cachy has a statement on this: What ensures that Cachyos will continue as a project, and what is the roadmap? - #2 by ptr1337 - CachyOS Community - CachyOS Forum

yes cachy-os has actually 4 main devs. antergos started the same way… hope and confidence is no guarantee.

1 Like

Arch?

A forum post is an official continuation plan now? mmhh, OK, let’s go with this:

  • only 4 people
  • his parents have the access in case something happens. Let’s just pretend he never is in the same car or plane as his parents so they never get injured at the same time:
    • his parents are qualified to continue the project?
    • his parents know they will have a new hobby called Cachy OS if their son passes away?

If you are just playing around, all these hype distros are fine. But if you need continuation, use the primary distro. If you want to use a fork for serious application, make a 5 year track record or similar a requirement. If a fork grew well, had no major issues, and has an actual improvement over the primary distro, and has a good management structure and community, for 5+ years, it probably will make it longer. Especially if the core team grew to more than at least 10-20 people.

Ultimately I can’t imagine many distros are financially lucrative and rely on donations. There will be added pressure to do something else in life once the creators hit real life and have bills to pay. Then the distro either goes big (also financially) or withers away. Ensuring quality is a lot of work and there are hosting expenses etc. that is the whole reason Manjaro did the GmbH and sold services to commercial clients.

3 Likes

/thread

Honestly, this is the answer, and has been since 2018, really. Anyone still on Manjaro who knows of this forum’s existence, I struggle to have sympathy for.

You could download the package from another machine, but then you’re in dependency hell.

The best way to fix this is to boot back into the installer USB, mount your new install and arch-chroot into it. the chroot will share the live environment’s network and you can pacman -S anything you want.

5 Likes

This is really good to know. This isn’t the first time I have made this type of mistake, so I will keep this in mind for the next time I make this sort of error. (because it certainly wont be the last time I err…)

Thank!

1 Like

I switched to Manjaro about 5 years ago. When I say, “I switched…”, that means paving 9 different devices from Atom tablets to 64 core workstation beasts and laptops ranging from newest to 17 years old - across 4 people including gamers. It also means friend and family members get my Distro of Choice at the time.

So I’ve got a lot of experience with Manjaro.

Technically, I very much appreciated the GUI installer and the mhwd utility that actually fixed many things after a failed update or patch, usually around video drivers. And it really helped on Hybrid laptops with both iGPU and dGPU splitting. It was really nice that everything defaulted to iGPU and let me use dGPU for Blender and Ai workloads.

Overall though… I had several failed upgrades that broke the FDE setups. Not as much as Ubuntu/Pop_OS did previously, but it happened and to the point that Live USB booting didn’t allow me to fix it - so each machine had to paved over.

To wrap up, there are many QoL issues logged that never had any movement, even though they were supposedly “prioritized.” After years of no movement , two I’ve been involved in, that indicated to me it was time to find a other distro.


I was already experimenting with other distros before this Manjaro overtake started a few months ago. We ended up with the Universal Blue images of Aurora-DX and Bazzite deployed on most things (there are issues with older hardware though, so those remain on Manjaro until I figure things out without Wayland and old Nvidia GPU LTS drivers support projects).

So far, there was one system that broke FDE on an update after reboot. That was easy to fix: pick the last immutable image from Grub to boot and wait a few days for another updated image.

1 Like

yes it’s a good decission to watch for an alternative while manjaro is still maintained, to be prepared in case that manjaro evaporates itself. for now it’s still maintained although the updates for the stable-branch are lagging behind while testing and unstable are getting updates. this might be the result that there is already a new release in the pipeline that’s scheduled to the end of april and there’s no need to maintain the stable release cause it gets a big update with the new release.

there are no news what’s ongoing behind the curtains. the last infos are that the ‘rebels of the mutiny’ got in touch with a legal expert to sort out their paper-work. i doubt that there’s a fast ongoing in this case cause the transitioning of a business into a non-profit-organisation has a lot of traps and it’s still unclear if the manjaro-g.m.b.h (the business part) is willing for a deal.

the actual status is that phil mueller (the owner) will deploy a new release of manjaro at the end of april. sounds to me that he is not really scared and the work of the ‘rebels’ is not really such important to stop the development. who knows… i’m still watching what’s ongoing and will report when news (if ever) arrive.

1 Like

Coming from a commercial background many of the issues we faced where software drove hardware changes! ( and not just in computer equipment).

Because compatibility of interface was a big factor.

New developments in “ required” upgrades could cost a staggering amount of operating budget.

You had to be damn careful choosing software or you risked lives and equipment, not to mention loss of production.

Open source does not always answer the question if your production equipment uses closed source drivers.

Emulators and vm’s are a gamble at best.

Equipment manufacturers using closed source or propriatary software literally shut out any competition on the choice of os!

That is the primary reason industries lag way behind in upgrades.

just some minimal news. the founding of the e.V. as community is in progress and they expect to finalize the legal paperwork in the next weeks but there are no news about the future and the transition from a business to a community entity. i’ll report when newer infos arrive.

1 Like

As much as I’m done with Manjaro (it has been “superseded” by other Arch spins), I’m interested to see how this goes.

It’s a very interesting case of community rebellion to save a dying (dead?) horse. I wish them the best of luck, maybe Manjaro will become worthy of inclusion in tier-lists again.

there are no real news actually. the last news had been that the founding of an e.V. is in progress. this can last longer depending on the legal aspects the foundation has to fullfill but this would be just the first step. this foundation has to deal a contract with the manjaro-company to hand over the business-belongings and the demands of the foundation are very curious. why should a company hand over it’s company-infrastructure and the whole brand to a non-profit-foundation without compensation ? everything is discussed behind closed doors and we have to wait for news. manjaro is still a business-driven distro and is doing business as usual with ongoing development and support.

3 Likes

the latest news is that the foundation is now a legal entity that is run under the “manjaro Project e.V.”. the interesting note is that they cannot run under “manjaro e.V.” cause the owner phil mueller doesn’t accept the use of the manjaro brand so they run it with the “Project” labelling to circumvent the branding-violation. imho phil mueller will not accept the takeover and this e.V. will have to run their project without substantial support from manjaro and will have to fork it eventually. i expect more news in the upcoming weeks.

5 Likes