The end of manjaro - the ugly divorce

yes manjaro is a construct where the commercial-departement offers enterprise-solutions to business partners and the manjaro-departement that develops manjaro with financing by fund-raising, merchandise and money from the commercial-section for work that is used in the enterprise-departement. that’s the reason why i was always confident that manjaro is a financial-solid construct (even if the money was always a problem) but it wasn’t depending on donations as only income-source.

1 Like

then be aware what happens if this distro gets “a community-driven-distro”. there was a big dispute cause a developer invented a telemetry-service that he wanted to include into manjaro to earn some additional money and it was the owner of the company who stopped it cause it is a violation by german and european laws (no eula, no opt-in). that’s something annoying me actually, there is this storybook of the brave developers with their honest rebellion and the bad owner who is to blame for everything bad. i don’t buy this story

2 Likes

The “developer” you’re talking about is one of the owners of the company.

There are two owners, they both wanted MDD so they could convince companies that they had a large enough user base to make it worthwhile working with them. It was also so they knew where to devote the limited resources to best develop the distro for the users.

It was stopped because a large part of the community objected, and false data was being submitted eg ext5 was one of the filesystems reported and that doesn’t exist.

Please stop making stuff up.

5 Likes

hello and welcome to the forum,

i’m not interested in this kind of discussion as it is already going on in other forums. the role of this “second owner” etc.. don’t bother me cause neither me nor you can give more details to it. moreover this is something that the manjaro-company has and will talk over behind closed doors with their legal advocats. that’s no technical issue and not my intention to speculate about.

sad enough that manjaro disrupts cause of a bad game of power and influence.

So basically, for an old guy reading this, may we say more of the same?

The devs fighting, ‘x’ or ‘y’ distro userbase in turmoil, future uncertain, which distro to hop over or when, etc. etc.

Am sure i’ve seen this before :slight_smile:

Now if, on the other hand, with platforms like github available to us all by now, folks sat down and did a part each, with nice, detailed instructions for normies to read.. for the same, base distro?

But nope. Let’s make another distro. For the same limited, niche userbase. Until we get a job, until we fight, until life starts weighing down on us.

Sad. Predictably sad more like.

2 Likes

If you were an actual “old guy” you would know this is not how humans work. Point to me an example of the above in any field, where people just come in and collaborate peacefully. A place where there are no fundamental ideological or technical disagreements causing strife.

Competition is a biological imperative, because you cannot have all your eggs in one basket. What happens if something wipes it out or the leadership makes a big mistake? Everybody sinks with the ship.

See for example Microslop CopilotOS (calling it now, before the end of the year they will rename windows).

On linux if a distro blows up or goes rogue it is no big deal, you can jump ship to a similar distro and be fine.

you’re joking, aren’t you ? my hair get’s less every day and this grey-color gets more and more dominant… i’ve choosen this distro cause it had a commercial background leading me to the conclusion that it will not vanish cause some egocentric hobbyist blow up the “community-driven-project” after some time cause their ADHS-syndrom is so ego. you need some kind of professional leading and if a dev want’s to rebel… then kick them out and replace. that’s the only way to get a project running, period. my actual problem is that i’m using manjaro as underlying system for my virtualized vm-infrastructure. porting vm’s to another system → very easy. porting the underlying system of your vm’s to another os → it sucks.

I find this conclusion amusing. Commercial products and distros with commercial backing get discontinued or dramatically changed all the time at the drop of a hat.

See for example CentOS, which after it was bought by RedHat is now a completely different thing and everybody jumped ship to Rocky (which is founded and run by the Centos founder) or Alma or Oracle Linux.

Or all the drama with Ubuntu and this year’s Canonical NIH project bs that nobody wants and will be discontinued in a little while.

Or the drama about the future of OpenSuse Leap after 16 since their corporate upstream distro (suse linux) wanted to go down the atomic route like fedora silverblue. I dont know how that ended or if it ended yet btw.
They made opensuse slowroll though (it is rolling distro like their Tumbleweed but does the rolling in waves a bit like Manjaro.

There is drama on opensuse again after their corpo overlord decided to discontinue the Yast system configuration application, and it has been poorly maintained for years.

There is drama with Fedora (technically owned by RedHat) wanting to drop 32bit support as mentioned above by others.

There was drama in TrueNas when redhat decided to drop the support of glusterfs (a lighter weight distributed network filesystem) and this caused them to change their whole plans for TrueNas and go with docker and incus instead of kubernetes.

The future is uncertain about Spice protocol too (used to connect to a vm’s graphical console) for the same reasons, red hat dropped it.

Sure lets just fire a bunch of core devs and staff, because people are just cogs in an assembly line. There is no such thing as loss of insider distro-specific experience that cannot be replaced but only rebuilt over time as your new workforce learns the system.

I understand your frustration but this is just life especially in IT. A few years ago at my job we had to scramble to find a free replacement for CentOS. Now a lot of clients are feeling the squeeze from Broadcomm’s Vmware and want to change ship to something cheaper like maybe Proxmox or redhat OpenShift.

1 Like

You started off real polite! Well done :slight_smile:

”if you were an old guy you’d know”

I do know; that people don’t read, sure as hell don’t read/take note of what’s historically done and done and done again. I know how younger minds tend to work, had one myself.
But i also know that later gens have the “meta” effect/benefit that ours did not.

And that this too they fail to meaningfully take advantage of.

I additionally know that to despair to such an extent that everything is.. uninteresting, merely factual is sign of mental/spiritual degeneration; not me.

I lastly know that to invite argument over nothing at all is sure a sign of immaturity.

And immaturity, contrary to popular opinion, has nothing to do with age alone; plenty of people younger than you have amassed maturity aplenty. Friction provides that; what we call living.
Too much Western living/first world cuddling can also have its disadvantages, you see? Folks don’t really live. So they remain immature. Lack of perspective.

Try not to be too edgy with strangers. Too many folks are way too edgy. You see too many folks being too edgy, instantly you know this is something you shouldn’t be :slight_smile:
Don’t be like the masses, will never help you.

I just doubted one of your statements and explained why i thought it was the case. But feel free to make this about me

i can understand it 100%. but to the other hand this is the reason why i was always looking for something commercial that is non-commercial if i can maintain it myself. everyone that made himself depending on a product like vmware is nowadays in big poo.

Are you referring to dropping actual 32-bit distros? Most major distros do that or already did.

Or is that about the part that Steam seems to need? Wouldn’t that be up to Steam to move up to 64-bit on their end? (I apologize if this is a stupid question, I only heard that partially since I’m not a gamer).

I have no clue, but I’m surprised anything modern or powerful still is 32 bit.

But obviously this isn’t drama like “Fedora will be discontinued” if they remove a 32-bit feature.

I assume small distros die all the time. but how do large distros like Manjaro usually die? They didn’t have a small user base, but obviously this doesn’t mean resources. and obviously this seems to be an “infighting” death. and that may just be the final chapter and infighting had lead to a sub-par product for a while? (No offense, i mean compared to the improving competition)

Did we ever have distros die that were relatively large and well regarded? And did they just run out of money, or developers? For example, Debian is popular (even if not the best distro for many users), but if no one donates, or volunteers start caring or age out, it could die.

I think it isn’t bad new distros appear, if only the good ones survive. Darwinism would be good to get better distros. but the hype-train keeps bad distros alive for too long. And we only have a few actual distros (Arch, Debian, Suse, Ubuntu, Fedora, Void, Nix…). if someone would create an actually new independent one, it wouldn’t be that bad, but i also wouldn’t see the point since we already cover all release models.

But the real problem is, each of the above main distros, only has 1-2 really really good forks (if even that). Rest of the new distros aren’t really doing anything new, they just modify a bit, mix in some new DE (and probably break a lot of stuff and can can’t keep up maintaining it well).

Edit:

Edit: Apologies for going off-topic.

No i meant removing 32bit support from their 64bit distro. Fedora dropped 32bit distro a while ago. That is both at kernel level and in userspace libraries. It is not just dropping multilib packages. I think the kernel feature is called COMPAT but dont quote me on that.

If the upstream distro kernel drops that feature the downstream distro will have to ship their own kernel with that feature enabled, and pay to sign it to work on secure boot enabled systems.

Steam client is just a glorified Electron application. They can go 64bit easily. On windows they are already going 64bit since december last year.
The issue is older games are still 32bit, and no game dev is going to invest time to port old games, assuming the studio still exists.

So for gaming distros like Bazzite it is a problem.

2 Likes

If it comes to (Windows) games, isn’t Wine (with its 32bit prefix for example) or Proton layer basically handling this translation so that there are no 32bit libs involved on the Linux side - or am I missing something?

In the past, wine/proton applications run in native mode so if they are 32bit they need at the very least kernel support for 32bit and maybe libs.

Afaik, Recent wine (10.8) has a mode to run 32bit application as 64bit, so it finally becomes kind of an emulator. In that mode you should not need mulilib or kernel support for 32bit applications

As with all things wine, this may or may not work with some applications, although it should.

this is not a thread about fedora nor 32-bit cause of gaming. if you wanna play windows-games then stay on windows but don’t disturb this discussion with this nonsense.

1 Like

Seems like a thread about your opinion, and apparently that’s all that matters. :wink:

it’s a thread about the insults when a distro vanishes that is used as server-os and it’s not about 32-bit and gaming.

Skimmed this thread, read up on the situation, tried to understand both sides, and I can’t find any strong arguments for Phil’s perspective on this. It really just seems like he’s not managing things well, not listening to feedback, ignoring people when they try to make changes, not giving access to important infrastructure and just generally being the core reason for the downfall of the Manjaro project.

It’s my view that the restructuring of the project is needed, to get the project back on track. If there is any chance of Manjaro surviving, it needs to be restructured, however, that does not guarantee success. If it doesn’t get restructured and the core problems remain unaddressed, that will only accelerate it’s downfall.

5 Likes

well he stopped the paychecks to developers that claim themselve that their work is a laughingstock and at the same time these developers claim that he denied that this work aka. “laughingstock” got published. find the error.

i can understand that the work wasn’’t professional enough and you can’t present laughingstock-solutions if you have to please commercial business partners when you run a business. i don’t wonder that these guys want to turn the commercial-business into a “community-driven”-one cause they don’t have to give guarantee to their “work” if its a simple hobbyist driven one.

the opposite is the actual situation where manjaro has reliability to customers that pay and you are in a situation that you can be charged for compensation if the product fails.