Switching to Linux...Need help, Desktop environment and Window Managers

Hello guys,
Yesterday i was looking for software replacements today asking about things I know nothing about, but I find very interesting and want to play with it.

That is window managers and Desktop environments. In my quest in switching to Linux for programming and just really for fun I haven't really found a Desktop Environment that I love, I really like KDE Plasma so far because it feels like windows just with a lot of custom tweaks, but that isn't why I am switch to Linux I am switching to spice things up and to have absolute power (Mahahaha) over my computer, So today I am wanting to know information about Window managers as a replacement for a traditional Desktop Environment ( may have terminology incorrect ). I am interested in i3. Things I really want to know are can I use a standard desktop environment and i3 together, say I want my girlfriend or a friend to be able to use my computer with out having to know all my shortcuts could i do that so I can switch between Plasma and i3 (or other desktop). Also how hard is the transition switching to i3 and to Linux at once ( is it to much for a mere mortal). Is it something I should have a lot of experience with Linux first to use or is it something a noob like me could manage with the right amount of time and research. I have been watching videos on da Youtubes since i woke up today and it looks like a lot of fun to use. I have a quad monitor setup how does i3 and others work with muit monitor setups, that is kind of a big concern since losing those isn't an option for my desktop, may still use it for my laptop.

I believe gnome has a way to integrate i3 on top of it. Have not tried it yet but something for you too maybe look into.

Will definitely look into that. Kind of the solution I am looking for that or if i can make it work like having 2 desktop environments where I can just login to what session I want being i3 or Plasma.

In most login manager you can switch your desktop manager before you login. so you could just set something like a guest account to KDE plasma and have your account be i3

i3 will have a steeper learning curve than regular linux because it is all terminal based.

I have never used i3 with multiple monitors so i cant speak on that front

1 Like

I3 is built upon xrandr so for multi-monitor setup you should be familiar with it at least.

I've used i3 with a multi-monitor setup and it works quite well actually.

That is exactly how i hoped that would work. currently I have whatever the Antergos default login manager is and when I was playing with a VM that had both GNOME and KDE Plasma i could just switch.

I thought that it would, but I guess this is something i am going to try on my own to see if i can do.

I will familiarlize myself with xrandr, currently have no idea what that is.

Will look into it and Yeah since i have gotten into Linux i tend to ask a question or 2 every week.

i have my #ult linux tutorial series designed to helped newbies get introduced into linux

dont be afraid to ask any questions. there are many people in here who know the ins and outs of linux

1 Like

Do you know X is, or what Wayland is?

No, this is prettyl much day 2 or acually using Linux and learning about it outside of installing Linux and applications.

My basic rules to newbies can probably apply to you. I funno what all you have tried but....

mate > kde > xfce > budgie > awesome > jwm > gnome

I push people to try stuff in that order because the workflows are exact opposites de to de. I love using workspaces whereas someonemay not, so that is sprinkled throughout that line. Theres more I could add to it, but if someone gets to gnome and is still unhappy I point them at freedesktop.org and amiwm and hope for the best.

Alright, so to learn about how linux works go install arch linux in a vm or on a junk computer. If you can't do that then just read the arch wiki about installing and see what al goes into it.

I have tried most of those, but thanks for the advice I really like KDE so far and gnome. Gnome i really hate the top panel it feels so useless and i don't like the full screen super to look for applications since i currently use it a good bit. KDE really enjoy.

Just a normal arch install, not using something like revenge installer i assume?

never heard of it.

But yes, do it manually. Set aside like 4-5 hours one night and use you favorite VM of choice.

and read stuff like this:

Well then heres what I can say. Go get netrunner rolling, you can get the torrent on linuxtracker. Run it in a VM, play with THAT Kde. The way they set up KDE there is by far my favorite implementation of Kde ever but because that OS is dead, ish, and there is a way to do it that way but I don't know how because I'm not balls deep into kde 24/7.

And if this is Day 2, try MATE, XFCE, and maybe awesomeWM (learn how AWM works first).

will do or at very least look into it

have tried both of these will look into awasomeWM

Will do, anything that helps me understand Linux better.

1 Like

Well linux is only 1% DE XD tonnes more to look at. The DE is just where you are comfy.

Yeah, I am still wrapping my head around all of this, trying not to get to invested on one DE yet, and trying to stay open, good point in 1% i mean it's free i can change whatever whenever I am not locked in to anything so i should just take full advantage of that.

No you should learn one and use it until you're bored and need something new. It'll happen, trust me.

Alright then, Noted. I mean that is part of the reason i am switching to Linux i am board with windows.

1 Like