(Re-write!) Welcome to Linux!

Okay so I decided the previous write up was not structured and friendly enough to really teach new people stuff they can grasp easily, So any information please feel free to add it in, Any questions will be answered to the best of our knowledge, and lets see if we can get this sticky!

Part 1 - What is Linux?

Linux is software, The software its self is not an operating system, It is a kernel, A kernel is something between your hardware and software, kind of like a translator, it sends Input/Output requests for resources or for hardware to request specific things from the software.

Everything has a kernel it has to, so the software can talk between hardware and software, everything from your toaster to you TV has one, and to be honest, It could be Linux running it, Just because you cant see it happening does not mean it is not happening.

Linux is often spoke of Like Windows is, An operating system, But it is not, Windows has a kernel called 9X for 95/98/ME editions of Windows and Windows 2000 and beyond currently use the NT Kernel, Linux is the same as NT, sort of, Its not designed or programmed the same way, Apple OSX uses something called BSD (More later).

So the name Linux is just the kernel not the actual software you use personally, but its always there.

The kernel is spoken more of in Linux than Windows and Mac, as we can actively edit the kernel our selfs, updated it when a new edition is released and even use the testing kernel to try new additions and fixes out, so you will hear from people, check your kernel, unlike Windows.

The Linux Kernel is updated around every 3 months, which makes it very dynamic compared to NT, and with this comes added benefits as well as drawbacks.

Good and Bad Points

-- With more updated can come more security, Exploits related to the kernel are patched, But the downside is more can surface when a patch is applied, there is no real way to fix this, the Devs just have to stay on top of the code and monitor it the best they can, which they do.

-- It can be changed into anything you want, As you have free access to build your own kernels from scratch, But again the downside is if you mess up building your own kernel you may not have support for it, as others may not have seen the issue you face.

-- Because The Linux Kernel is so dynamic, it can be used on almost anything, IBM love this setup, they can use their own architectures for their own mainframes and systems, and control every aspect, But just because there is so many architectures supported, means that unless specifically developed it can cause issues using ports.


Maintenance of the Kernel. 

The Linux Kernel is also maintained differently to NT and Apples version of BSD, People all over the world contribute to the kernel every day, no matter who you are, you can develop and add into the kernel, But it does not mean you can get your code in, It works like this.

A major update is around every 3 months give or take, to make the update cycle so fast multiple people submit their code, which is then broken into patches, which show the lines which need to be changed, added or removed and can add support to devices and apply with fixes, Devs post patches to mailing lists and it can be commented on and changed if need be, When the patch is close to completion it will be handed over to a senior dev who will then review the patch, and if deemed ready, it will be signed off and handed over to Linus Torvalds (The Father of Linux) He has the final say over what goes into the kernel, If he passes the patch it is then implemented into the kernel.

All this makes for a nice, smooth and fairly structured development release cycle, Now each kernel is not without its bugs, this is why any user can try testing kernels and submit there issues with the kernel back, any issues found are resolved to the best of abilities and then the kernel is rebuilt and put back out onto the internet, If you have ever herd of Nightly builds, these are the same things.

The reason the kernel is maintained to such a high standard is thank to Linus, he is very careful of what is allowed into the kernel, and gets annoyed when things don't go plan, sort of a perfectionist in my eyes, but there is nothing wrong with that, just means higher quality for us at the chance of a delayed patch.

Remember this part well, for later it will also roll into other parts.

Part 2 - So Linux is not the OS, so what is?

Okay so they are not really known or labeled as Operating systems here, Because there are so many they are known as Distributions, and there are a lot of them to try out, some are community developed such as Sabayon and Mageia, some are company developed such as Ubuntu and Red Hat Enterprise Linux.

There are also things known as specialized distros, these are created for specific subjects, a good example is Kali/Backtrack Linux, this is a security related distro and a dam good one at that, It is based off Debian and has almost every hacking tool you could wish for and more, I dont believe any one hacker knows or understands every tool going, it is possible but very rare.

The major and recommended starting distro on the internet is Ubuntu, here on the Tek we like to show people other distros and let them know that there is multiple choices for you, mostly free.

So lets start with Ubuntu.

 

Ubuntu

Ubuntu is seen as the face of Linux, to the people who have played with Linux understand it is not, as there are many different distros out there and there is one for everyone, A lot of people in our Linux community don't like Ubuntu as much as others, Say Debian which is what Ubuntu is based off.

To me it is not a good distro, I have had multiple times where the system has crashed on me for install AMD Catalyst etc, You may not have that issue, So try it, Also it uses Amazon on the Dash panel (Like Windows Index searching) so if you like to shop at Amazon its handy.

The Distro is based on testing software, not stable, this does not mean you will be on the absolute knife edge of technology, it can take a while for Ubuntu to get some stuff Fedora and Gentoo get early, This is more for their users than anything else, Although again, I have seen issues within Ubuntu and I personally don't find it as good as what it once was back in the days of Ubuntu 8/9

It comes with a desktop environment called Unity, its easy to use but can be a bit bloated for older systems, I like its looks, but I like more lightweight things, so take that in mind.

It also seems to be moving away from what the rest of the Linux distros are doing, by installing software that does not seem to be present on other systems, this is a choice by the devs and may pose conflict later.

It also has Ubuntu Software Center, It is not as good as using the actual terminal, but it works well for finding stuff you did not know existed or do not know the command for.

Debian

Debian is a rock solid distro, one of the most stable out there, it is minimal as in there is no software installed apart from what you need, and its brilliant on servers, I have again had issues with Debian, but with every distro I have had issues, it works brilliantly with most hardware out of the box and is well documented as most stuff that works on Ubuntu works here, just think of it as a better Ubuntu, a more stable one, You can go bleeding edge with this distro using Debian Sid, but I cant report on stability or reliability as I have never used it.

Fedora

Someone has to be on top of Bleeding edge, and this is the distro for it, If you want stability clashed with pure bleeding edge technology this is the distro for you, Although I would not call this a newbie friendly distro as such, It is still easy to use, Korora is the user friendly version.

Fedora is the testing station for Red Hat Enterprise Linux distro, the technology added into Fedora is then pushed out towards RHEL when its ready for enterprise use, this can take time, but it is brilliant for home users who want a high performance machine.

Korora

This is the user friendly version of Fedora, maybe not as bleeding edge quite, but still on the edge, it has GUI installer similar to Mageias Control panel, while not as refined still works well, so just imagine a super easy fedora.

Mageia

Based on Mandrake Linux, it uses RPMDrake (urpmi) to deal with its packages, and is one of my fav distros, its easy to use, the control panel is super easy to use and works very well, its fast and while not as minimal as Fedora but still small, it performs on par with Fedora in my experience, so if you don't mind the extra software for your ease of use, you cant go wrong here.

Gentoo

Gentoo is a very advanced distro, based on rolling release formula, it cant be rivaled in performance, how you ask? well this is because of how it compiles things, with other distros like Fedora which install and download pre-complied packages, Gentoo makes you compile them, this is not as hard or scary as it sounds, the terminal does most of the work for you, which is nice, but due to setup you make when you install the distro, your packages compile to your system specifically, so the drivers are for your PC only, no other generic drivers, making it un-rivaled in performance, its well documented, but if you want this but feel intimidated by the way you have to build it from the ground up, the next distro will sound like a present for you.

Sabayon

Sabayon is Gentoo on easy street, its GUI based all the way around, it can use Portage, which is what gentoo uses so if you want to compile everything, go ahead just be prepared to wait ages, if you don't mind still fast performance but not as fast as pure gentoo, use RIgo manager, its easier than compiling and works just as well with no performance hits, its brilliant for gaming also, with its minimal bleeding edge setup, you really cant go wrong, pure performance, ease of use and steam/ATI/Nvidia pre-installed, its one of the easiest distros to use.

Chrome OS

Chrome OS is also based on Linux, it uses a form of Gentoo, it still has the portage package manager similar to Gentoo/Sabayon, but requires no user input, as updates come on the fly, these updates are tightly controlled by Google regardless of Google considering it a Open Source System, although people can still contribute via reports. This is possibly the easiest OS to use on the planet, as it is designed at people who just want the internet on an inexpensive device, but Chrome OS is slowly sneaking its way into Education and Business sectors, which is a good thing :).

Tiny Core Linux 

If you want a super small footprint this is a good distro to use, its a strange one I have not had much experience with but its biggest size is 60MB, Yes 60!, It is designed to run from RAM over storage, but it can work on storage.

 ....More Later...


Part 3 - Gaming in Linux

Gaming in linux is still a grey area to many, Yes we now have Steam, which is brilliant for home users who just want to play games, this does not come without its draw backs, we have some major titles like Metro Last Light but we still dont have things like Skyrim, now this is not steam and linux's fault, its the devs fault, they may not see reason to develop for linux for many reasons, one could be because they feel the market is not big enough, or they would not make money, or the dev cost for linux is too much, all valid points, but the games we do have over here works very well, I tested Metro Last Light on Linux using Sabayon 14.01, and I could play it higher than Windows would allow me, this was using Catalyst, As the system its self does not take as many resources compared to Windows, it means we can play games at higher settings without the need to increase our hardware power.

SteamOS could push game devs to push games over to Linux , I also think more games will appear this year on Linux, which is all good, You could build a £500 machine, Install something like Arch or Sabayon, get low resource usage via the system and more to push into your games, If the Windows gaming market still lasts after Steam OS (Which it will but why should it MS dont give a shit about Windows Gamers) you can always run a virtual machine and play games with more power than Windows could offer you via virtually increasing cores from the CPU.

So when someone says "Ha your on Linux you don't have games" (I got this when I was on OSX, Still had games though), Explain to them you can run Wine/Play on Linux, a Virtual machine or games are native here, and laugh at them, this OS has the possibility to make our system run harder without the cost and hardware strain.

You said Wine/Play on Linux, What is this?

This is a nice bit of software you can get for free in Linux to translate Windows apps to Linux can run them, It works well for a lot of things, but not everything is working fully, But there is a database you can check to see if you app works and how well it works.

Play on Linux is the GUI version of Wine, as far as I know its slightly outdated compared to Wine, but not too much, It also offers a easier way to install apps, in comparison to Wine, but it is better to learn to use Wine, as it works better.

Crossover Linux is also another app, this is a paid application, it runs around £30, it works the same as Play on Linux, but you get Commercial support from Crossover, compared to community support, its up to you also if you wish to pay for it, I personally don't as I prefer Play on Linux or Wine.

 

Part 4 - Drivers for Linux, What's the deal?

Well drivers on Linux work, very well, I have had better sound from ALSA than Creatives sound driver, this is installed by default on most distros, and works well, GPU drivers are not always as easy to get, yes there are open source drivers but these do not work as well as Catalyst in some situations, I mostly opt for Catalyst beta, I never opt for stable, the drivers are generally stable enough on both Linux and Windows to run Beta daily. if you have issues you can always remove the driver and go for a stable one.

In the last year of playing with Linux, I have not encountered a distro with a missing driver, the drivers come from the kernel on here, so chances are your hardware is supported.

Also do not worry about installing things and having trouble, when terminal commands are issued the terminal normally puts applications into the correct places, this includes any drivers, the Catalyst driver requires a similar setup to Windows, which is download the file, extract it, then run ./ on the file in terminal, catalyst will launch and it will be like windows.

 

 

 

Very good post man. Linux makes me happy (: The Linux world is getting very exciting, and I'm happy to see a spike in interest here on Tek Syndicate. Now we just need to spread the flame...

Thanks, but its far from finished :) and yeah its gaining traction, but I fear with MS latest slandering of Chromebooks that we will loose a few who where thinking about chrome OS, Cant do offine and is useless offline, Can do office, better... and MS is also usless offline lol... but to be honest who is actually offline these days?

 

Good point. But I am actually offline for at least 30 days a year due to living in the middle of fucking nowhere Louisiana.

In that case then its all useless lol, I want one of them laptops though get the quad core, Put linux on it then take a pic and send it to ASUS mwhahahaha

Would you care to exlaborate what you mean by redhat enterprises and fedora going rogue 

yeah sure, Ill update the post :)

Whether they are going rogue or not, pffft, but they are doing a few things that some people - including myself - don't like:

1. I've been using Gnome 3 for years. It's as smooth as OSX, really good for productivity. Gnome is basically a RedHat project, most of the maintainers are RedHat employees. Now in most distros that offer Gnome, there seems to be no geolocation dependecy (geolibs is something else, it's just a list with countries and their IP ranges to help a user localize a service geographically, it's harmless, this is about geolocation reporting, not based on the IP, but based on the data on the system), but on Fedora, it's made into a necessary dependency, in that uninstalling the package, will lead to breakage of prinicpal Gnome functionality. That means that a user will have to use nominatim to obfuscate his geolocation all of the time in order to feed the services integrated in the groupware functionality of Gnome with wrong information, just to prevent these from mining real data from the user.

2. Both RedHat and Novell are momentarily working on a live kernel update function. That is actually a very useful thought, in that when the kernel sees that a software needs a certain kernel module, it can download that module and load it into a running kernel mid-session. Like wow, great... no, not necessarily... because where would this functionality be most important: a. for 24/7 running servers that won't need to be taken offline for security patches and feature upgrades of the kernel... so far super great, wow, fantastic, but b. for proprietary applications or hardware that need proprietary kernel modules, that taint the kernel, and can pose a serious security risk... and that's where the problem really is, because in reality, only dedicated servers use only open source package sources, desktop users, for productivity sake, often have no choice but to use proprietary drivers or proprietary software, and it would be a really bad thing if tainted packages would be able to update or load autonomously into the kernel. On top of that, this feature will also cause a lot of breakage, because kernel updates are great, except when pigheaded anti-open-source hardware manufacturers can't provide proprietary driver modules that actually compile into the kernel without problems... which is still the case with every single kernel update and nVidia modules, but is also the case for applications like Oracle VirtualBox or VMWare VMPlayer.

3. RedHat and Novell are putting their upstream community development versions, Fedora and OpenSuSE, on a leash. RedHat is rearranging the Fedora product line to move away from typical community projects like spins (versions of Fedora that are targeted to particular use case scenarios, like Electronics, or Gaming, or Media Production, etc...), and is synchronizing the Fedora release schedule and release products to the RedHat release and development cycle. Fedora will be numbered like RHEL, and will not be named anymore, and Fedora will follow the RHEL release cycle. Novell has prohibited the SuSE staff from working on OpenSuSE on company time, so OpenSuSE has been forced to extend their release cycle to once per year instead of twice per year. This is not good for development, at all. Fedora and OpenSuSE are the upstream of RHEL and SLES, which are the commercial products of RedHat and Novell. The effects of this decision, which was taken 2-3 weeks ago, was immediately felt: for the first time in like forever, Fedora was not the first distro to release a kernel update, but was preceeded by Arch, Gentoo and Mageia.

4. RedHat has assimilated CentOS. CentOS was a community edition of RHEL, specifically for server use. CentOS is also the basis of many other products, like Xen hypervisor for instance. By assimilating CentOS into RedHat, CentOS stops being a community open source project, and becomes a commercial RedHat open source project. It also gives RedHat control over functionality in things like Xen Server, because that's based on CentOS, and if RedHat, which favours kvm as virtualization solution for obvious reasons, determins that CentOS shouldn't release certain functionality that would help Xen Server, it can decide to do that now. I'm not saying that they will, in fact I'm pretty certain they won't, but there is that possibility, and the effect of the balance of power is great in open source development.

5. RedHat has been working with nVidia. That's not a surprise, and there's nothing wrong with it, because nVidia really needs a lot of work, and RedHat can deliver solutions because they have the knowledge. However, these solution were vetoed against release, they are not to come to the users. At the same time, RedHat has orphaned the AMD Catalyst drivers from the Fedora community unofficial non-free repo, and that goes very far, because there is no problem with the Catalyst drivers compiling against any linux kernel, and they orphaned Catalyst just before the major HSA upgrade, that would put nVidia cards even more to shame in linux, and therefore, the only reason they did it, was to please nVidia and hurt AMD. And all of that on non-official non-free Fedora community repos... that goes very far...  Again, in the field, nobody cares because it's still easy enough to install Catalyst on a Fedora install, but it's a nuisance with an alarming aspect to it, because the nVidia proprieatry drivers never ever compile correctly against an updated kernel, they are nothing but trouble, and they are not orphaned.

I've been using Fedora and RHEL for years, and have always been very happy with it. But my gut feeling about these events was pretty bad, and I always follow my gut feeling on these things. In the end, it's all about quality, and the mechanisms that guarantee quality.

So I've migrated completely to Mageia now. Mageia is basically the same as Fedora and OpenSuSE, it even shares maintainers and developers, and they have proven that they can deliver a lot of added value in terms of ease of use and security, they are completely non-US, and they are a not-for-profit community organization with a fixed legal base that guarantees that they remain just that. Mageia has a release schedule that is more relaxed than the Fedora release schedule, but there are just as many updates, and it's pretty bleeding edge, with a few minor exceptions. The software portfolio in the Mageia repos is almost the same as Fedora, also with a few exceptions, but Mageia is an RPM distro like Fedora and OpenSuSE, and can run yum natively besides urpmi. In practice though, the Drake Software Center is really good, even in comparison to yumex, and Mageia offers a lot of extra features that facilitate the use, even by the n00best of n00bz. It comes hardened out of the box, and has it's own live security audit functionality, that works really well and spans the entire system config. It also runs very fast and is as stable as you would expect an RPM distro to be, so top scores in terms of reliability and availability. Commercial support is provided through industry partners that are typically less monopolistic players, and Mageia is much more focused on smaller regional companies to provide commercial support. The process of migrating to Mageia was painless and very quick (only a few hours), and in terms of productivity or even use, there is absolutely no difference, with the exception of the fact that we've also switched to KDE instead of Gnome. Mageia has a number of other benefits, in that it doesn't provide a separate commercial and community edition, so for instance, whereas in Fedora, the repos would always have the latest version of Firefox, which has always been a problem for things like flash, plugins or CSS, Mageia release by default sticks to the ESR versions, which are much more stable and fast than the development releases, while also having guaranteed security update priority.

As an experienced linux user, I was tempted to move everything to Gentoo, with Sabayon as an alternative for non-linux-experienced productivity users, but in the end, the new Mageia 4 came just in time, and had all of the convincing qualities required. It was a huge step up from Mageia 3, and I really liked it as soon as I tried it out.

I'm still running a Fedora Rawhide version though, and will continue to run it, just as I now also run a Mageia Cauldron version, and I still run other distros as well, like Gentoo, Arch, and even Debian and Slackware. I was determined to stick with Sabayon for entertainment use, and run a Windows container in that for older games, but I've decided to just use a Gentoo container on Mageia now for linux games, because I haven't even fired up my Windows container since April 2013 or so, and that was just to update the system and the games that I don't even play anymore anyway, so I've opted not to install a Windows container any more and just only use linux, but since most games and the Steam client are not open source, and can therefore cause breakage and security problems or human right violations, I still prefer to run it in a managed kvm container in a separate distro, and Gentoo has a lot of benefits for gaming, because of the inherent performance it offers in a minimal configuration.

As you said though, RHEL with the dynamic kernel updating will cause taint and security issues, also break a lot of programs that need a specific kernel and dependencies, which in theory yes is a superb idea, but in the real world a shit idea, unless they have someway of making programs that are not updated to the kernel work, and to be honest that is near impossible, again making the idea not worth it.

 The GNOME thing also, without tweaking is awful experience OOB, its also slow I find, and the fact you cant remove geo-location without any breakage is also stupid, it kind of binds you to it without a way out, unless you are pro at fixing things, GNOME2 is still the king of the GNOME DE imo, but as you know I dont use it, I use XFCE/KDE (Distro dependent)

The tightening of the distros is also another bad thing, not allowing the community to release fast and responsively can hurt them as well as other distros, Fedora was the pinnacle of technology release, and maybe still is, but the fact RHEL seems to be going evil, and because HSA will put nVidia to shame so they orphaned the driver is another fact money comes first, which can never work in a community effort, I understand they are a business, but nVidia should have thought about FOSS before and decided to make their move towards it instead of slandering it and sticking with Microsoft, and then when it gets traction think, Oh yeah we can now make some money out of it, Where as AMD decided to go first hand with it, like all technology they think forward, not in green.

When I was on Fedora I loved it, the fact I was on the edge of the knife, running the latest and greatest with stability and security backing me up, but as soon as you said the Rule #1 is broken and the fact RHEL are deciding with deals over community wishes annoyed me to some extent, adding to that I never got AMD working without breakage (More of me than the driver) and KVM wouldn't work due to some xorg error, I had to move, If Fedora ever goes back to its old ways I will go back in a heartbeat, it is still my favorite distro.

Moving from there I went to Sabayon, which I am back on for now to test the KVM issue see if I can make any headway here, I am doubtful of it but we shall see, But I do prefer Mageia over Sabayon, again its based on RPM, its install manager is easy to use for the times where I don't know what package name I need, but I did have some issues with last install, easily fixed with a reinstall no doubt, the fact it was moved to a semi bleeder is also good, in the last week been on it I had multiple updates, which makes me happy and the fact my security and stability is more assured over Windows.

And unfortunately I cant leave Windows 100% just yet, I enjoy gaming a lot and again windows has the major share... For now, And I doubt SteamOS will change that, as with the fact its going to be out-dated, Maybe they should move to Gentoo ;) Google got it right, make it easy to use with no terminal (Although I like my terminal)

But with the last section of your final paragraph, 'and Gentoo has a lot of benefits for gaming, because of the inherent performance it offers in a minimal configuration.' is a reason why I think its better for my desktop to stick to Sabayon, performance is everything (Bit of a speed freak).

But as said, things are changing in the bleeding edge area, it always is, and this is sometimes good, I don't see RHEL doing anything good with there choice of orphaning AMD and then switching to a GPU that cant even support half of the options available in Linux, and the fact they don't believe HSA will beat their stuff, time will tell with the 14 series drivers, I give it til summer before HSA becomes the next best thing and nVidia copy. 

I have comments for quite a few things you said.

The Linux Kernel is maintained by a community and glued together by Linus Torvalds, know as the father of Linux.

And don't forget like every single company that does anything with IT. Independent contributions are pretty small.

the most well known distro is Ubuntu, but is no where near the best

Unnecessary bias.

Debian is insanely stable and is brilliant on servers, its minimal and still like lightning

And it can be rolling, bleeding edge, brilliant on workstations, desktops, netbooks, embeded, NAS, pretty much everywhere.

Ubuntu is known as a mcdonalds distro, its thrown together, works but not as well as some others in my personal experience, The company behind it Canonical Ltd is beoming rather nasty, nothing compared to Microsoft but still rather bad, It is suggested to avoid this distro now, and go with the ones mentioned in paragraph 3/4 of this chapter.

That's so much bullshit. Ubuntu is 90% frozen debian testing packages, the server edition is really awesome and has a few goodies developed by Canonical which do not exist on debian but you can have the same setup on both. The LTS versions make sense for servers because you don't want stuff to break when you're in production and also on desktop because Ubuntu is used by many companies, institutes and on private desktops who simply do not care about the operating system and want to accomplish a task. Their system is tailored for them. You might not like it but saying it's crap, buggy, unstable or insecure is simply wrong. It's a good system, it might not what you search.

the default for Fedora has Geo-Spyware installed

As does every web browser, as does everything which sends ip packages outside of your LAN.

so its no longer a community distro, which is what you look for in a good Linux distro, using these methods they could lock down the code and hide all sorts of stuff.

That was a very recent decision and you currently can't see the implications but one thing is sure: You can't lock down or hide any GPL'd code. That's why we have free software in the first place.

Adding to this with SteamOS rolling out which stopped the AMD Catalyst driver from installing using any commands without a fix, which breaks functionality of the system in turn breaking other peoples stuff.

Since when do we consider proprietary drivers as something we have to take care of?

They brake all the time, the kernel ABI is not stable and will never be stable. Fuck AMD and especially fuck Nvidia for their proprietary drivers. Don't blame anyone else.

You can use text only environments, Brenn loves these ;) The two I have used is Fluxbox and i3, both good but I am not ready just yet to be text only, this is not really recommended for new users.

There are no text-only desktop environments. What you mean are probably lightweight window managers.

Security is handled differently over here than on Windows, you dont need security software, The Linux Kernel is already harderned against almost all attacks, it is not impossible to hack, but its a hell of a lot harder than Windows and OSX.

Security on Linux is a joke on most systems. It doesn't matter that the kernel is rock solid, it's user-space applications which are buggy like hell and probably have more security related bugs than popular software on windows. Also privilege escalation is still a huge problem due to the X server.

I could, and maybe should, write more about the whole issue.

Windows has a team, We have a communtiy, this may not seem much, but I shall show you the power of a community.

The linux kernel itself is a company dominated thing. Many distributions are also company specific. The only huge base-distribution which is complete community project is debian.

 

And don't forget like every single company that does anything with IT. Independent contributions are pretty small.

Yes but the final option is Linus, he decides if it makes it into the kernel, the final answer if from him, So to speak.

Unnecessary bias.

How so? Ubuntu is so prone to breakage more so than any other OS, due to the company developing it thinking more about money than anything, going the way of RHEL it would seem, Adding to that apart from ChromeOS it is the best marketed linux distro around, I dont even see any advert for Fedora/Sabayon/Mageia/Arch etc etc.

And it can be rolling, bleeding edge, brilliant on workstations, desktops, netbooks, embeded, NAS, pretty much everywhere.

Yes but have you attempted to run a bleeding edge Debian distro, it has no where near the stability of something like Gentoo/Sabayon or Fedora, adding to that just because the packages are in testing does not count it as bleeding edge, half of  the tech in Fedora has not even appeared in Deb.

That's so much bullshit. Ubuntu is 90% frozen debian testing packages, the server edition is really awesome and has a few goodies developed by Canonical which do not exist on debian but you can have the same setup on both. The LTS versions make sense for servers because you don't want stuff to break when you're in production and also on desktop because Ubuntu is used by many companies, institutes and on private desktops who simply do not care about the operating system and want to accomplish a task. Their system is tailored for them. You might not like it but saying it's crap, buggy, unstable or insecure is simply wrong. It's a good system, it might not what you search.

Then try run them with a stable situation, It wont even touch RHEL, and these packages are not outdated, adding to that why the heck would you want testing packages on a server? seriously, Reliability and security is the most important thing on servers and you want to run testing on an enterprise? would not go down well at all, Hence why I said Debian is a brilliant server OS, its rock solid and does not break easily due to the packages been tested and tested before it hits stream.

As does every web browser, as does everything which sends ip packages outside of your LAN.

This is true yes it does, but you can hide you activities on the internet using HTTPs protocols, ones inside the OS that are always phoning home cant be stopped without a firewall rule, which can cause more breakage, This is the same with adobe on windows and OSX.

That was a very recent decision and you currently can't see the implications but one thing is sure: You can't lock down or hide any GPL'd code. That's why we have free software in the first place.

This is again true, but the fact they want to lock down the systems towards users is a stupid idea and will take it out of the FOSS market, if you can view the code or they are locking the system down, it no longer is classes as FOSS, I wouldnt class RHEL as FOSS.

Since when do we consider proprietary drivers as something we have to take care of?

They brake all the time, the kernel ABI is not stable and will never be stable. Fuck AMD and especially fuck Nvidia for their proprietary drivers. Don't blame anyone else.

Regardless of OS drivers break, the fact is RHEL decided to stop AMD support so nVidia wouldn't get crushed via HSA, it was a marketing move pure and simple, then they decide to make a statement about we stopped dev cause we had no one to do it, bullshit, you didn't want to make your new partner look bad, Adding to that SteamOS needed support for nVidia for people on Windows with nVidia drivers, so they need to make their OS look good, so they also could disregard AMD, again rule 1, dont break anyones things.

You can use text only environments, Brenn loves these ;) The two I have used is Fluxbox and i3, both good but I am not ready just yet to be text only, this is not really recommended for new users.

There are true only text environments, have you used Ctrl + Alt + F1? that is an environment, they may not be true only text environments but with a little work you can make your whole OS true text.

Security on Linux is a joke on most systems. It doesn't matter that the kernel is rock solid, it's user-space applications which are buggy like hell and probably have more security related bugs than popular software on windows. Also privilege escalation is still a huge problem due to the X server.

I could, and maybe should, write more about the whole issue.

 

Do I would love to read your opinion on why this is, you try to break into the system using tools, it will take you a hell of a lot longer to do it to Linux than Windows, and the X server has been patched, I watched the 30/c3 on X server exploitation and while yes there are bugs, these are patched rather quickly, how is it also a joke with apps like PaX and SELinux? then the real virus removers are linux based? Do write about this issue, I would love to see your side :)

The linux kernel itself is a company dominated thing. Many distributions are also company specific. The only huge base-distribution which is complete community project is debian.

If the Kernel is a company dominated project, Why can anyone around the world contribute? if it was surely each company would have its own kernel, and the Linux kernel would be divided. I would like to point you to the Linux Foundation channel as found here with the video I would like to show you.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yVpbFMhOAwE

Companies assist with the kernel, but so do single users, its a community effort, just because businesses add into the mix does not make it company based only, Universities add into this also, as well as Home users.

Debian is not the only community driven effort, Fedora was and still currently is community based, for how long? unsure... Sabayon is also community, Mageia is again another and so is arch. You have to think this also, Porting and redeving apps is also a contribution which goes into the package managers and any updates can be pushed out to stream, more community effort.

 

I do understand where you are coming from, but I do find a few issues with your points, while valid, I feel that a lot of stuff is biased towards debian, which again I do like, but not as much as Fedora.

But Thank you for sharing :) Also if you do write this post about security, if I find any points I will add them into here with props to you :)

 

Ok, I really like the read I would add a bit about the differences between binary and source packages maybe go a little into repos and dependencies.

 

Also lets not have a Debian vs Gentoo war because we all know the Arch users will come in and sucker punch us. :P

First of all, a lot of change is coming to Linux in the next year. X is being phased out and replaced with Wayland - Wayland DEs and WMs are popping up (Hawaii, Weston has great functionality, and with the swc framework, new tiling WMs can come about with great ease).

Security issues in the userspace is just as bad on Windows, so you can't blame Linux for that.

There aren't necessarily text based WMs, but you can run DEs, Gnome, for example, with a frame buffer and tmux, just without the Gnome shell. X can run, and you can just use a VT - no need for all of the unnecessary GUI ;)  I believe Droidie was referring to my tiling WMs, though (I use Bspwm), and since I really only use terminal-based software for my daily use, all of my screenshots are text only, so it's understandable why he might have mistaken them for text-based.

Arch? Pschh, Solingen Linux is where it's at (it's my very shitty CLFS pet project). 

In all seriousness, though, I am probably moving from Arch to Crux tonight.

You don't have to answer to every bit. Some stuff is simply a supplementation.

How so? Ubuntu is so prone to breakage more so than any other OS, due to the company developing it thinking more about money than anything

If you can't back it up with any numbers it's just an assumption. Also interesting is that Canonical lost money every year which you can lead you to the assumption that they don't really care about money.

But in the end it doesn't matter as long as they make GPL code. And they do.

Yes but have you attempted to run a bleeding edge Debian distro, it has no where near the stability of something like Gentoo/Sabayon or Fedora, adding to that just because the packages are in testing does not count it as bleeding edge, half of  the tech in Fedora has not even appeared in Deb.

No, and running bleeding edge anywhere with the purpose of actually doing something is insane, in my opinion. But bleeding edge Debian is called experimental and some people use it.

Now again, as long as you can't back up your claims that there is much stuff in Fedora that's not in Debian, I call this bullshit.

Then try run them with a stable situation, It wont even touch RHEL, and these packages are not outdated, adding to that why the heck would you want testing packages on a server? seriously, Reliability and security is the most important thing on servers and you want to run testing on an enterprise? would not go down well at all, Hence why I said Debian is a brilliant server OS, its rock solid and does not break easily due to the packages been tested and tested before it hits stream.

There are very few repositories that are more stable than Debian testing. One of them is Debian stable.

You seriously underestimate how stable testing is.

This is true yes it does, but you can hide you activities on the internet using HTTPs protocols, ones inside the OS that are always phoning home cant be stopped without a firewall rule, which can cause more breakage, This is the same with adobe on windows and OSX.

That's bullshit and doesn't make sense. You only need an IP address to estimate the position of the packages. It doesn't help when you encrypt the data. The IP address is on a lower level which must be unencrypted because it is needed on every node to route the packages (well, not always but that's how it currently works).

The package only provides information and another tool uses it. If you can't configure the tool, it is broken and should be fixed. It's not a reason to dismiss a complete operating system.

This is again true, but the fact they want to lock down the systems towards users is a stupid idea and will take it out of the FOSS market, if you can view the code or they are locking the system down, it no longer is classes as FOSS, I wouldnt class RHEL as FOSS.

It doesn't matter what you call FOSS because it's defined pretty clear. Free and open source software. RHEL definitely has huge amount of FOSS in the system. I don't get what you mean with locking the system down. You effectively can't do that with free software - that only works with open source software.

Red Hat is an awesome company. They make money by writing free software and pay programers for writing free software. They are one of the companies were you actually can make a living by contributing to the free software ecosystem. Yes, RHEL might not be for you. It's aiming for corporations and all the work they do is free for you.

Regardless of OS drivers break, the fact is RHEL decided to stop AMD support so nVidia wouldn't get crushed via HSA, it was a marketing move pure and simple, then they decide to make a statement about we stopped dev cause we had no one to do it, bullshit, you didn't want to make your new partner look bad, Adding to that SteamOS needed support for nVidia for people on Windows with nVidia drivers, so they need to make their OS look good, so they also could disregard AMD, again rule 1, dont break anyones things.

They didn't actively remove any code or support. When a company like AMD produces drivers for an Operating System in a way it is not intended to work they don't have to expect it to work. The same goes for Nvidia. I don't care which proprietary driver stopped working because they are all shit and nobody should ever have to use them.

"we stopped dev cause we had no one to do it, bullshit" - Oh, so you know exactly what's going on internally? Of course they stop developing stuff that doesn't make them money. Why do you blame them? It's not their job to please everyone - they want to make money with free software. You might want to read about Occam's Razor.

 

There are true only text environments, have you used Ctrl + Alt + F1? that is an environment, they may not be true only text environments but with a little work you can make your whole OS true text.

Those are called virtual terminals (ttyN), they are not desktop environments. Don't mix that stuff.

Do I would love to read your opinion on why this is, you try to break into the system using tools, it will take you a hell of a lot longer to do it to Linux than Windows, and the X server has been patched, I watched the 30/c3 on X server exploitation and while yes there are bugs, these are patched rather quickly, how is it also a joke with apps like PaX and SELinux? then the real virus removers are linux based? Do write about this issue, I would love to see your side :)

When you find hundred of bugs in one piece of software in the duration of a few weeks the possibility that there are much more bugs is relatively high. 5$ say that you're vulnerable (= using adobe flash and an X server with root permission).

Yes, it's better than security on Windows and Mac but it's still extremely bad. SELinux doesn't help too because the possibility that you have to configure it yourself is very high. So yes, you can make it pretty secure but that involves much work and knowledge and as long as it's not secure for everyday users it's not secure enough.

I'll write something about it.

If the Kernel is a company dominated project, Why can anyone around the world contribute?

Why not? All companies have the same interest.

Companies assist with the kernel, but so do single users, its a community effort, just because businesses add into the mix does not make it company based only, Universities add into this also, as well as Home users.

http://lwn.net/Articles/579081/

All independent contributors together (people who do NOT get payed for working on the linux kernel) are responsible for 11% of all changes in the 3.13 release. That's what I call company dominated.

Debian is not the only community driven effort, Fedora was and still currently is community based, for how long? unsure... Sabayon is also community, Mageia is again another and so is arch. You have to think this also, Porting and redeving apps is also a contribution which goes into the package managers and any updates can be pushed out to stream, more community effort.

Yes, true. Most linux _distributions_ are community projects. The linux kernel and distribution key-components (X, wayland, systemd, gcc, gtk, qt, PA, …) are mostly developed by companies.

I do understand where you are coming from, but I do find a few issues with your points, while valid, I feel that a lot of stuff is biased towards debian, which again I do like, but not as much as Fedora.

They are both great, they are for different people. I don't care about which distribution you prefer, I just don't like when people talk trash about completely good distributions.

May take me a day to get the information together, so expect it on by friday, saturday the latest :), I know what they are just dont trust my self to do it off top of my head lol

First of all, a lot of change is coming to Linux in the next year. X is being phased out and replaced with Wayland

Ha, I'll only believe it, when I see it. People said the exact same thing one year ago, and one year before that.

Wayland DEs and WMs are popping up (Hawaii, Weston has great functionality, and with the swc framework, new tiling WMs can come about with great ease).

Woha, such awesome DEs! They can even rotate your windows!

Hehe, but seriously, the xdg_shell protocol doesn't even have support for minimizing, a taskbar is currently impossible to implement without hacking something together, and better not talk about tiling because it doesn't work at all. No min-max size hints, no size steps, no information about whether a window is transient or not, no information about if the client is fixed size. It's all in the making and looks promising but there is still so much stuff to figure out.

Security issues in the userspace is just as bad on Windows, so you can't blame Linux for that.

I don't blame anyone for it but it's bad and needs to be fixed.

you guide minus the ongoing flame war should be sticky 

There isn't much to it.

Source packages simply contain the source code to build the binaries, binary packages only contain the binaries.

Packages have dependencies which means that they don't work without other packages being installed. When you install a program, for example, it uses a toolkit like gtk or qt, other libraries which provide functionality like playing a video and maybe the program executes a script. That means that you need qt,the libraries and the script interpreter installed on your system. It doesn't simply download everything the program needs and throws it in a directory because other programs might want to use the same libraries and programs.

That's why every package has a list of dependencies. Your package manager then locates those packages and checks them for dependencies until it found all dependencies. It then compares the list with the list of installed packages, pulls down and installs every missing package.

That's pretty much it but I can go into more detail if you want.

So every discussion is a flame war nowadays?