With everyone locked up due to “the thing” we have seen an explosion in use of non-free proprietary aidsware like Zoom to “help” people connect with their loved ones, even hold government meetings…sigh.
Not being a fan of being bent over I went on a quest looking at Free Software alternatives and one that looks very interesting and mindbendingly easy to set up was Qtox. I’ve used it in the past but thought I’d consult the Level1 well of wisdom to hear what everyone (on the right side of the IQ bell curve) thinks about it and what your potential concerns are with it. If any code spanner monkey has any idea about looking at the code that would be dope.
I’m just wondering how on earth it works peer to peer without bootstrapping servers with a list of peers to connect to? They say that “Tox has no central servers that can be raided, shut down, or forced to turn over data — the network is made up of its users. Say goodbye to server outages!”
The Whonix project has it included in their OS so that is at least somewhat of a stamp of approval.
Tox https://tox.chat/index.html
ZoomAIDS https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2020/04/security_and_pr_1.html
3 Likes
This is neat, I’ll have to give it a once over.
I’d be interested in sitting down with some of the other members of the community (preferably people across long distances, maybe some east US, west US, and europe folk) to give it a test?
It’s not really something we can test by ourselves.
Sounds like a good idea to do some testing. I’d be down for testing all the way down here in New Zealand. Will get some QubesOS VMs set up tomorrow for testing.
Lol… can’t test by ourselves? Qubes OS with multiple VMs with VPNs - that’s how I usually talk to myself 
The article on the lack of security of Zoom is really insightful, thanks! Also the application looks interesting, but the bootstrap servers leave me a bit concerned still.
Yep, I’m also a bit very concerned about that lol. Maybe some wireshark, snort or some other packet sniffing is in order. I see there is an IRC channel for Qtox on freenode but you have to join to talk, I’ll try join there soon and see if I can get some answers.
They really should have some diagram on their website to show how the hell the peer to peer process works without central peer lists.
The fact that they say “say goodbye to server outages” can only be interpreted as NO need for bootstrapping servers which I’d be very surprised that is even possible. I could see it working by the public key somehow having your IP address included - but then it should stop working if your public IP ever changes or you try call from a coffee shop. Or maybe your IP address change but it uses other people in your contact list to update your current IP to friends again - hoping that at least someone’s public IP remains the same. I have seen a talk by them where they mention there is other people’s stuff flowing through your node so not good for low bandwidth. Must have answers…
The question regarding how initial connections are made is covered at 15:00 minute mark: Grazer Linuxtage 2019 - Tox, secure open source P2P communication
Preconfigured nodes.
1 Like
I guess the question is how we know those nodes aren’t compromised or something.
There’s never been a single service that was completely free of a supernode or something like that.
1 Like
Thanks for the answer, I’ll take a look at the video asap.
Meh. In the end a self hosted solution like a mumble server for talking probably a better option. I would probably (definitely) be more keen on Qtox than skype-syphilis or zoomAIDS but if you could easily set up your own hosted server and just point to that IP it might be better. They do mention that is possible but definitely not via GUI from what I’ve seen.
Hard to be certain about any of it in the end. If you are using skype it is pwnt by microsoftcock and the NSA. Terrible that the internet and services are such a sh!tshow. Will always have to place a certain degree of trust/distrust in whatever we use on computers - though we should keep demanding striving for better.
Maybe @wendell and co can make a video on a variety of solutions - self hosted on Linode and another option for 3rd party solution like Qtox which is fairly simple to get started with or hosted on a plug server (pi like device) in your own house. Just an idea.
1 Like