Proton Mail starting to look SUS

TL:DR they censoring complaints and posts that might not look favorably on proton, they have also been rapidly expanding and advertising

4 Likes

I guess the old age is true - you either die a hero or live to become the villain.

Sad to see, nonetheless. :cry:

5 Likes

Is this actually Proton or is it some fanboy-mod gone rogue?

The post being taken down definitely has nothing to do with the drama that it would have caused when the community got into it, so rather than wading through 800 comments and sorting out the ones that don’t follow the rules, they just took took down the post.

That tracks. We preemptively take action here because we want to avoid flame wars, this seems like a similar practice.

Though, our members tend to be far more level headed than redditors, so we don’t usually have to take broad-reaching action.

5 Likes

I don’t see anything wrong here. I’m not a reddit user, but I wouldn’t be surprised if posting screenshots of helpdesk conversations is against their rules. We also don’t know if this user was spamming to get this post through either. Too much here is left to speculation.

In any case, a company doing business has to comply with whatever government regulations exist in their home country, so there really isn’t any true freedom or privacy. Pick whatever offers the right balance of privacy and convenience for you.

4 Likes

Its modded by proton and not a 3rd party.

Its also worth noting that complaints of their slow rollouts and email features.

I’m getting the vibe that anything negative on them may get axed which isn’t a good look combined with ads and rapid expansion feels corporate to me, wish I had more time to focus on self hosting but I doubt I can compete with a proper DC

Edit: also glad to some descents here that might be good news

I’m not sure this is censorship by Proton.
Seems to me more of a case of trying to bypass support queues and Proton being on it. It could also be a wait for approval due to the use of images (who would trust a Reddit user not to post NSFW content and not tag it just to troll?). Last but not least cross posting is highly frowned upon so why try your luck on the incorrect sub?

I’d rather not defend corps of any kind, but this seems trying to stir up drama instead of trying to understand why things are going the way they are.

About them turning up the stove on ADs I cannot comment.

2 Likes

Well if the other comments are true, IF they have been taking down negative comments. I think. Struggling to see things your way about NSFW photos. That seems a bit draconian to ban photos in the subreddit compared to other subs. Bypassing support kind of makes sense. Also point to you, I have not sat down and done a search to see if they havE left up plenty of other negative posts

2 Likes

My comment was more punctual on this issue. I didn’t investigate further either. I didn’t see much more of a strict ruling in the sub in this case.

Banning for a photo upload yes, surely draconian. Not unheard of having to wait for manual review.

We got some work cut out for us then!

1 Like

Seems a pretty big reach to connect a reddit mod to the core of the company. I get being cautious and all, but at the end of the day NO company cares at all about you (or any end user) more than they do about themselves. Proton may well be the lesser of the evils, and they may not. If you’ve got stuff that’s actually sensitive, then there would need to be many more precautions taken than using a public paid service to achieve “security”.

*edited for spelling as usual

6 Likes

That reminds me they never made good on their promise to reorg as a not for profit

Well said,

I have had Reddit blocked at a DNS level on my network for about 4 years. It’s far to easy to find the wrong answers these days.

4 Likes

How well they run their subreddit is very low on the risk assessment for me.

Their client code on the other hand is of paramount concern.

The whole idea of proton is that we shouldn’t have to especially trust the people running it.

1 Like

I’ll add one more thing…Lets not make a habit of expecting a forum controlled by a company to be a good place for the community to have balanced discussions about said company :slight_smile:

It would be nice if we could, but alas, it always leads to heartbreak.

2 Likes

My favorite conspiracy theory (all but confirmed these days) is that all of reddit is a psyop by the air force.

3 Likes

I would not be surprised if that were the case. Most of the users on Reddit are likely bots. I sometimes read the comments and see the obvious AI responses. I would love to watch an unfiltered documentary on the use of bots online and in social media.

1 Like

Why the airforce in particular?

1 Like

Airforce runs Area 51…

4 Likes

If actually space aliens were on Reddit it would explain a lot.

3 Likes

https://old.reddit.com/r/degoogle/comments/1m82x90/proton_has_to_be_kidding_banned_account_with_all/
I read the op and some replies.
I guess using a disposable email address as a backup/recovery email broke their TOS

It makes sense as if you are hacked or locked out to have another recovery method, but privacy minded people who are de-googleing are not going to want to make another email account. I think there’s a opportunity for proton add other forms of account recovery, as it seems like a catch 22 to email support about your account suspension when your email is suspended.

Also I think it is unproductive for people to say you should have backups and to treat the cloud as disposable.

It’s the same as telling a person who’s home burned down they should have bought fire insurance or telling a person they shouldn’t have bought a Apple product after finding out Apple would rather have you buy a new device than repair yours. Louis Rossmann has said that we should acknowledge the issues when companies screw over consumers. We really should the OPs have a entry in the consumer rights wiki

Given that it would fall under this category

https://consumerrights.wiki/Consumer_Rights_Wiki:Inclusion_guidelines

On a different note, I feel like proton mail has shown up more in the recent YouTube sponsorships. They really should take some of the budget on marketing to improve their product and let users be promoters.

3 Likes