I was reading that article last night as well as other sites take on it (anand, toms).
Definitely sounds like shady marketing bollocks.
The timing (right before the 290x launch unveiling) is just too suspicious
Failure rate
The failure rate discrepancies between the two makes (as reported by other system builders of high quality) aren't high enough to warrant dropping amd.
Hardware performance
Even after all this time an overclocked ghz edition (clocked to around 1200 core clock) of the 7970 *still* performs well against the 7xx series from nvidia so I wouldnt think performance is an issue.
Drivers / dual gpu
Nvidia do have an edge here, but Amd are making progress.
Bottom line, I think its a desperate move from a company that knows its been backed into a corner.
But I'll have to disagree on the drivers. Sure AMD has a few bugs, but so does Nvidia.
My 680s are getting buggier with every driver update. The last decent driver was 306.97. After that overclockability went to hell [from +200mhz / +500mhz memory to unstable at +50 / +200] and my WQHD screen or the two 1080p left / right of it flicker randomly. Chrome has a problem with SLI enabled, one monitor keeps losing DP signal randomly. And so on and so forth. While I've had a few issues with AMD drivers in the past, like my mouse cursor blurring out in StarCraft II, it's a minor nuisance compared to this shit that makes the PC close to unusable.
I should never have bought Nvidia and sticked with ATI as I have all my life before that ^^
And yes, of course it's marketing. I've seen many people saying that "Nvidia wouldn't do such a thing" completely neglecting that the funny guy dancing around the stage and mentioning countless times that he wants to blow all the "gamers" out there, is nothing but an actor. At the top of the company you got the shareholders qqing about not getting enough money.
Nothing new, and its really not like OriginPC really matters. Anyone who buys an OriginPC is just an idiot really.
Nvidia just wants to make sure their dedicated GPU product is still dominant. They have won the battle, but lost the war really when it comes to big contracts. There is so much antagonism for everything that Nvidia does, and yet none of this is really illegal or abusive of the system.
You can't compare Apple's abuse of the courts to Nvidia's abuse of exclusivity contracts.
... hearing some crazy talk there the 600 and 700 series cards are really good cards for past and present game playing... how they cope with 'round amd' is up for debate as it hasn't happened yet, no reason to bash them though.
If you read the SemiAccurate article linked in the OP, it was far from only Oracle PC who got paid for this. They were just the ones who made a big press announcement about dropping AMD cards and drew attention to this issue.
Illegal or not, actions like this do not produce a better product or provide any benefits whatsoever to consumers. This move is purely anti-competitive.
Also, what battle has Nvidia won? Not sure what that was referring to.
I am not bashing Nvidia, I just think that these practics are improper nad should not be allowed. I am also not directly comparing it to apple court trolling. My point should have been more like: They do improper stuff to sell their products just like apple :-)
When you don't have a good response to good new products form your adversary you should go develop new ones or be innovative or whatever but NOT do what they are doing right now. It is just because of reports like these that I would not consider buying Nvidia products (although they are certainly not bad! (just too expensive for their performance)). Unfortunately, many people do not share my opinion on this which is why Nvidia and Intel keep paying companies to exclude AMD products
I just hope that we will not get reports like this about AMD doing the same stuff. That would be diappointing.
But at least they were tongue in cheek, if this allegation is true and its nothing more than back room deals and marketing bollocks then it is a lot more evil than just some hammy commercials