Noctua Coolers for Threadripper | Level One Techs

********************************** Thanks for watching our videos! If you want more, check us out online at the following places: + Website: http://level1techs.com/ + Forums: http://forum.level1techs.com/ + Store: http://store.level1techs.com/ + Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/level1 + L1 Twitter: https://twitter.com/level1techs + L1 Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/level1techs + Wendell Twitter: https://twitter.com/tekwendell + Ryan Twitter: https://twitter.com/pgpryan + Krista Twitter: https://twitter.com/kreestuh + Business Inquiries/Brand Integrations: [email protected]


This is a companion discussion topic for the original entry at https://level1techs.com/video/noctua-coolers-threadripper
2 Likes

Sound was perfect Wendell.

Would have been nice to get some feedback on what temps you were seeing, numbers wise.

I do not understand why “maintenance” is an issue for water cooling. There really is not much at all if done correctly. Cost is a major factor though.

Bwahahah, that ending sounds like me… https://youtu.be/YYYMzJKxYig?t=9m24s

IMG_3803

Most recent project log update Look what.. Look what you just made me do <OH..!> @wendell

Hi Wedel,

I was wondering if the medium sized cooler would fit a 4u case? Any thoughts?

NHU14 should be able to clear 4U easily… ~1.28cm between top of the cooler/fan–rim and 4U chassis lid.

4U = 44.45mm * 4 = 177.8mm
NH-U14S TR4-SP3 with fan needs 165mm clearance

U12S and U14S was pretty amazing when they were released initially. I mean U12S was spanking most 120AIOs and U14S was giving the 240s a run for their money.
I’m honestly surprised Noctua haven’t released a dual tower, D14 type cooler. D14 will keep that fuker cool…

Hi bsodmike,

Yeah I ran the numbers myself too. I’m just concerned that 4u is only outer dimensions. You need to take into consideration thickness of the chassis times two, distances between chassis and the motherboard, motherboard thickness socket + processor. I’m just not sure if 1.28 cm is enough. Also is 165mm dimension including heat pipes?

I would like it to fit, but I have those concerns listed above.

Thanks.

1 Like

Thanks for the great review.
An off topic question – when are you planning to review the X399 Designare you used on your pass through video? I am about to pull the trigger for X399, and mainly want to know if there is out of the box linux compatibility like for the Aorus.

Got Fedora 26 running with qemu/kvm on the Gigabyte X399 Aorus Gaming 7, no problem (for the most part). I haven’t been able to test PCIe pass-through IOMMU yet, but apart from that it has been solid (so far).

As I recall Designare’s lure was the promise of Thunderbolt 3, but I don’t think there’s been much movement / updates on that front? @wendell may know more…

Two things. One, the asetek coolers do NOT work well with threadripper, and I have no idea why they promoted it. The baseplate is really what matters, as the 240mm enermax TR4 cooler does cover it, and perfroms better than these air coolers and larger asetek aio’s. Two, people get so worked up over core count and performance per core, but power draw is also a huge factor. The X models stock (1600x, 1700x, 1800x, any TR chips, which are all around 3.4-3.6ghz) all draw about 8 watts per core when under full load. This is compared to Intel’s 14w~ per core. So when we hear 16 core we think “this thing is a monster, its gonna gobble power and heat your home” but really isn’t much worse than intels 10 core.

Definitely to be completely objective, a Enermax TR4 AIO review vs the Noctuas is worth looking into.