I would recomend an asus for that sort of money like an Asus SABERTOOTH Z77 Its got PCIe ports for crossfire and sli and is made from high quality components. I recomend asus as a manufacturer and a lot of ppl do they are great but given that the board you got last was asus i figured you might want an alternative brand so i recomend GIGABYTE GA-Z77X-UD5H-WB same sort of features as the asus and same sort of price.
Personaly I dont over clock and I dont do dual gpu so I dont tend to spend that much money on a motherboard with that in mind im going to suggest getting a cheaper board like the Gigabyte GA-Z77X-D3H and an ssd. Its a mid range board but its all quality components and will still do sli and crossfire if at some point you want to do that and you can still overclock. Anyway thats what i would do and unless you want to do some mad overclocking its a better idea to save the money and spend it elsewear on your machine.