Minecraft server problems, but only Windows clients

I have a Minecraft server setup for friends. The server is at home on a system I have, and I use a VPS with GATE proxy as a reverse proxy. The 2 system are networked together with Tailscale.

For DNS I use my own domain with both A and AAAA records pointed to the VPS.

When others try to connect everyone on macOS or Linux (including myself) don’t have any issues. However people on Windows get “Connection Timed Out” errors all the time, even when on the same network as the macOS and Linux clients that are working completely fine.

How do I even debug this and what can I change to make Windows clients work better?

1 Like

Do the windows clients connect at all? Do they only time out after some gameplay? Or are they unable to even get that far?

Can you provide a traceroute ( tracert for windows cmd) from the windows client to the host?

This could help narrow down the issue. You also might need to forward a port

Edit: This is also a useful tool for checking minecraft servers: https://mcstatus.io/

1 Like

They sometimes connect sometimes don’t. Once it connects it works mostly fine.

1 Like

I tried traceroute already, everything looks like what they are supposed to be considering the internet connection and server locations. Also, a macOS client from the same network as the problematic windows system is not having problems at all.

I am not comfortable with sharing such info as that will expose my physical location as well as the IP of my private server.

1 Like

No need to provide IP’s, but glad you checked.

Only issues I could think of that would be causing this would either be a port not being properly forwarded or something isn’t properly configured on the MC server. Could also be some weird MS compatibility thing or client specific issue… but I’d think that to be unlikely since so many MC servers run on linux and most clients are on windows.

Have you made any modification to MC? Possibly changed any MC shell script?

1 Like

Vanilla 1.21.10 client, no mods no nothing. Tried with both prism launcher and the official launcher, same behavior.

1 Like

Hey, feel free to edit out your IP, or whatever material you wish to hide in screenshots, if needed/necessary

Sounds like Windows being its usual picky self with IPv6/MTU. Try forcing IPv4 by removing the AAAA record, or use -Djava.net.preferIPv4Stack=true. Also, double-check your Tailscale MTU and firewall settings on the Windows machines.

Before I sound like an idiot any further, what version of Windows are you running? Sorry I didn’t ask earlier, I don’t know why it didn’t come to mind.

The problematic system is running Windows 11

I tried disabling IPV6 inside the network card settings and that didn’t help

Maybe an mtu or ttl issue?

The voices tell me spanning tree protocol might be to blame. Try disabling it on your networks?

mDNS can also cause issues with windows sometimes.