Return to Level1Techs.com

Let's Talk Desktop Environments

I would like to know what Desktop Environments everyone is using and am particularly interested in what you like about your choice and what you don’t like. I think this could end up being an interesting discussion as long we don’t judge others based on their choices.

I’d like to see answers in the following format:

Current DE: KDE

Why do you like it?
I like the layout, it’s snappy and love the compositer

What do you dislike? Sometimes it’s a bit buggy with some GTK apps and it’s accessibility features, specifically text to speech are lacking.

Other notes: I also use i3 and MATE on a couple of PCs and enjoy them as well.

NOTE: Let’s try and keep it civil and keep distro discussion out of the picture. Feel free to post screenshots of your setup if you like! I know the temptation to troll is strong with this one, but 4 chan is just a click away!

Gnome/cinnamon
(well actually its windows 10 DE with open-shell but im assuming you meant linux and just didnt qualify that)

They seem to break the least often for me.

No real support for higher refresh than 60hz.
gnome being… gnome.
cinnamon being weird on anything that isnt mint

I used to like/use MATE because I really liked gnome 2 but screen tearing REEEEE

I dont know if thats actually possible here.

3 Likes

Current DE: KDE Plasma

I like it for the customization.

I dislike how buggy it can be at times.

I’ll also use Gnome on some systems if I just need something that works, and i3 for lower spec computers. On one of my laptops I don’t run a DE.

4 Likes

Current DE: Cinnamon

I like it for having that win9x look that i have liked with some modern things added.

I dislike that it runs on gnome, witch isn’t the best solution

I would like to use KDE Plasma or atleast try it out, cinnamon is just my daily driver DE that gets the job done and is simple to use.

1 Like

Using XFCE.

Mostly use XFCE, LXQt and OpenBox because I like the minimal overhead and I need it to work all the time. Only really use OpenBox anymore for laptops or when I have a system that I might need X at some point, depends on what I’m using the system for.

Using i3 on my main laptop. I pretty much just pull the SSD and cram it into a computer where ever I go, the laptops just for the rare occasion that there isn’t a computer where I am going. Don’t really use i3 much though, started using it for tiling terminals but at some point got lazy and said screw it, I can do everything from inside the editor.

Mostly just like Desktop environments and WM that stay out of my way and use minimal system resources.

1 Like

Cinnamon

My workflow is 100% terminal and web browser. The DE doesn’t matter, and this DE came stock on my Corp linux dist.

I use a KVM to bounce back and forth between a linux and windows desktop. Cinnamon doesn’t have an easy way to stop auto-detecting displays, without breaking the ability to then use a GUI to change display options later. So I guess my only real complaint is probably a corner-case, but still annoying to me.

I’m probably gonna switch to i3 soon.

1 Like

Gnome-shell with Arc Menu, Dash to Panel, and Desktop Icons extensions.

I keep it clean.

3 Likes

KDE

Its the desktop masterrace to be completely honest. Its up to date. It uses a superior programming language (QT). Easy to learn. No need to learn out of the box. Did not reinvent the wheel. Endless customization. I could go on why its superior to all.

Why do I dislike it?

Its still a bit heavy which can be fixed. Its buggy with GTK apps which are in an inferior language

1 Like

More screenshots, people!

KDE is okay, but they all seem to suck on two counts:

  • High DPI support is approximately Windows Vista quality
  • The mouse wheel can’t be reliably configured

MATE on my desktop system. Pros: lightweight, classic, easy access to configurations. Cons: doesn’t look modern (partially fixed by using themes), less supported than the main DEs.

Gnome Shell on laptop. Pros: modern looks, works better with touchscreens. Cons: configurations are harder to access or totally hidden, not a fan of gnome extensions through browser and shrugging off responsibility for maintenance onto 3rd parties for what should be default features

1 Like

i dont want to get banned

1 Like

Easily avoided, just apply a gaussian blur to your trans midget bacchanalian sheisser bestaility puke party wallpaper.

3 Likes

thats too much effort

Cinnamon

Pros:

  • Decent HiDPI support.
  • Reasonably free from distractions
  • Fairly lightweight
  • Quadrant snapping + Virtual desktops
  • Default file manager has all of the features I want, and none I don’t.
  • Works reliably with or without hardware-acceleration

Cons:

  • Default file manager (Nemo) is the most unstable app I use.
  • Gnome and Plasma have better HiDPI handling by virtue of fractional scaling.
  • Does not automagically handle Qt theming
  • Developed by Linux Mint

I’ll be giving XFCE 4.14 a serious trial once it hits Debian Experimental. I’ve always been happy with XFCE’s code-quality, but the lack of HiDPI support is a deal breaker. The next release has HiDPI support.

1 Like

That right there is sexy

Current DE: Gnome

Why do you like it?

It’s the default in Ubuntu and I do not have any big problems with it. I especially enjoy things like point and click configuration of wifi and bluetooth and a few other things.

What do you dislike?

  • Lack of tiling options
  • that when I disconnect my docked PC from my dual screen, all my apps gets thrown around and I have to manually reconfigure them
  • Takes up far too much screen real estate for some things like window borders and taskbars

Other notes

i3 fixes the three gripes I have with Gnome (albeit require some reconfigurations), so I’ve stuck with that for a while - but then I sometimes miss the dash to easily open up some programs, etc.

1 Like

Current DE:

  • Gnome 3.28

Why do you like it?

  • Large userbase means glaring issues are detected/resolved quickly.
  • Easy enough to customise and round off the rough edges.
  • Responsive enough so I don’t feel like I’m being gimped.
  • Large library of easy-to-install extensions.

What do you dislike?

  • Extensions often break because of “Don’t care” attitude of core Gnome developer team.
  • Basic functionality (e.g. brightness slider, date/time formatting) missing OOTB.
  • Lack of tiling options to make better use of wide screens.
  • Nautilus (file manager) search feature is pretty badly implemented; file transfer progress indicator is borked also.
1 Like

I just wanted to thank you all for responding. This has given me insight into what folks like and dislike and will help in my decision making while building my own custom distributions for friends.

1 Like

Deepin de
Pros
It’s pretty it’s snappy and has alot of gui options plus it’s on a good number of distros.
I love the simplicity of the de I run it on deepin native.
Cons
@Heimdallr “China” it has a China level spooky to it