Is Linux Gaming going to technically work?

Now I switched as Windows / Gamer to Linux well over 2 years ago. Distro hoped and started buying linux games. Ubuntu, Arch, Suse and Fedora lately.

As a gamer I want good CPU, GPU and decent ram. So I update. I started Intel / nvidia and cut a story short now Ryzen 1700 / AMD RX 480. So supporting Linux I went AMD because open source driver build into the kernel, hence need a modern kernel distro ! /no brainer Im a Gamer :slight_smile:

So over time these games broke. Paid for games.
Divinity Original Sin Enhanced Edition
Work fine under Ubuntu 14.* and 16.*. Switch to Fedora it worked then broke. Devoloper responce Only support Nvidia not AMD. OK fine I did switch to AMD. Sucks

Middle Earth: Shadow of Mordor
Fine on Ubuntu then Fedora till Kernel 4.13 then broke.

War for the Underworld
Fine on Ubuntu and Fedora till somewhere in kernel 4.12 then broken. Developer response

Hey Marten,

Sorry to be the barer of bad news but we do not officially support non-debian Linux distros.

The exact issue you are experiencing is a failure of our UI middleware, CoherentUI. We are looking to upgrade to the new version in the coming weeks, which may correct this issue but we don’t currently have a date locked in.

Unfortunately until that happens the best I can suggest is for you to attempt to force your discrete GPU to be used for the WFTO process.

XCOM2
Bought it while on Fedora and worked for months fine. Broke recently.

Finaly Ubuntu 17.10 is out and about with a shiny kernel 4.13 and I though yea, no more .deb excuses. But alas.

Divinity Original Sin Enhanced Edition: Does not work I bought an AMD GPU cause am an Idiot.
Middle Earth: Shadow of Mordor: Does work again :slight_smile:
War for the Underworld: Still broken. Same error from memory :frowning: I am back on .deb and still fail.
XCOM2: Does work again :slight_smile:

How long do I have before my games break ?

3 Likes

I think you have answered your own question. Linux games through Steam are compatible just so long as you are running Debian/Ubuntu or something from the same family. Or the distro maintainers are interested in maintaining Steam game compatibility (ie, Solus). If you choose a distro that falls outside that you are going to have a hard time. Steam in a snap format on a distro that supports snaps might be the easiest way for a distro that is not willing to ensure Steam game compatibility to achieve it.

What can you do? Move to a supported distro, try to persuade your chosen distro maintainers to start supporting Steam Games (Good luck with that) Make the necessary changes yourself. Hope someone “snaps” Steam.

6 Likes

I hope this helps
Paid 60 bucks (full price) for Fallout 4 plus 100 for a Win 10 license
It sucked and was a total waste of money

3 Likes

So you have no bones with Nvidia only support on linux ?

How long will the games work ?

Im starting to wonder myself. I dont want to spend money on games that just stop working because I buy a better GPU.

From what i’ve read so far, some distros support “steam-runtime”. Which i understand as a somewhat modified, possibly updated version of steam (Newer/modified libraries, runtime, etc)

Valve, do not update the libraries themselves therefore runs on old libraries. Instead the platform is updated, not the base libraries. Which can result in more bugs, than fixing the underlying issues, which many conclude are the outdated libraries that steam runs on.

Like @PendragonUK states. Choose another distro, which comes with these steam modifications (Solus, for sure is one. Also Manjaro i think) These distros are much less hassle, when compared to the amount you may need to tweak steam in other distros.

I remember Bryan Lunduke on his show, and co-host Matt Hartley discussed this very issue. Games on Linux tend to have problems later on, usually many years though.

Not enough of an expert to say whether it’s the kernel, libraries or both. But, hypothetically, if the games only state they support Ubuntu, then that’s the only sort of guarantee it will work.

Steam-runtime is the official version of Steam packaged by Valve. You can opt to run Steam in native mode. The rule if thumb with steam is run native as your libs will more than likely be newer and will override any older libraries in the steam runtime that you may have collisions with.

Check out the Arch wiki for some trouble shooting steps

I had some issues until running native.

In Arch,Manjaro,Antergos there is the package called steam-native 1.0.0.54-5 in the repositories. Which directs to: Steam/Troubleshooting - ArchWiki for more information.

With that installed, i havent had any problems running any title. The problems in never titles are often the developers, not steam itself. One example is, The Long Dark, which only runs under the locally selected folder and x86 version of the executable or at least did for some time.

1 Like

I’m sensing a pattern, here. I’d personally like to hear more responses from developers when their games suddenly stop working. It’s not something I’ve had a whole lot of problems with, but I have had it happen to one game in particular. But ultimately I think it would come down to developers being spoiled for choice and not really knowing what to develop for.

As excited as I was for the rise of Linux gaming, the timing was unfortunate. In the past handful of years, we’ve seen some pretty massive upheaval with the Linux GUI. X vs Wayland vs Mir, AMD completely changing their driver model, Unity vs Gnome, etc.

Honestly, the news that Ubuntu is abandoning Mir and Unity is the best news I’ve heard in a good long while. X is going away, Wayland is the replacement, no ifs ands or buts about it. Ubuntu has been the big player in the Linux desktop arena, but even with that edge, Unity had an air of uncertainty. Ubuntu + Gnome means that game developers have a solid foundation to build upon.

My two concerns at this point are:

  1. Will this upheaval have put a permanent bitter taste in the mouths of developers?
  2. What will developers do with the games that were built with Mir+Unity in mind, but now fail to work with Wayland+Gnome?

Is Linux gaming going to technically work? Yes. The developers need to stick with it, though, just like they stuck with Windows back when gaming in Windows sucked ass compared to gaming in DOS. Subsequently, gamers need to stick with it as well. If you’re running both Windows and Linux, then at least purchase all of your games in Linux. I’m sure the folks at Steam are paying attention to how much money is being spent by OS. Same with Good Old Games.

1 Like

I never had a problem with Steam games on Mint. I’ve been using Solus for a year now and my Steam games seem to run even better on Solus, with their Linux Steam Integration tool (LSI). Who knows, perhaps it’s the placebo effect, but they seem to run smoother. The Arch wiki page, referenced above, documents some of the issues that can be caused by the old Steam libraries. These were the problems which LSI was designed to address.

It seems to me that Ikey open sourced Linux Steam Integration, so other distros are free to use it. I’m not saying that it will solve everyone’s problems with all games, but it could help to solve some of the issues.

2 Likes

$60 for FO4? did that come with all DLC? apart from the windows tax, that’s not too bad- I boot into windows for FO4, Elite, and some DRM video stream sites.
Does it hurt, yeah, a bit, but when logged in to Linux, any games you buy does feed into steam’s algorithm, and I play whatever games I can on Linux.
Not gonna ditch the windows partition on idealistic reasons, and find more and more engaging titles do get ported to Linux.

1 Like

You reap what you sow.

4.9/10 is where you should be for compatibility and stability.

I say this because every time I’ve ever updated my kernel from the distributions default, something breaks.

1 Like

I feel your pain. Rust had the issue of Easy Anti Cheat not being finished because the people who make EAC stopped caring so I had to jump through 800 hoops to make the game to work with functional EAC.

But you know what, we on linux have the power to do that. To make something work in windows is a pain in the ass and OSX would probably cry and run off to a starbucks. In linux, we have the ability to go “No thats bullshit” and just do it ourselves, albeit with some extra work put in, but thats what we like doing anyways. We don’t mind it. As a previous windows user I can see what you mean by technically work. Where windows just has it, doesn’t really explain any of it it just magically works for not very many good reasons past rubber bands and duct tape, and you just expect it to do well. Windows has that advantage, where in linux you, by nature of the system itself, end up learning how opengl works, what talks to what, it just happens that way. Theres no good reason to HAVE to learn all of it, you just… do. Probably to fix shit.

For your games, I wouldn’t expect /much/ to happen with anything except war of the overworld. AAA devs don’t actually care that much they’re just trying to shill to as many people as possible. Though if its any confidence to you it worked fine on my arch box the other day and then I went to ubuntu, so you wight have a lib just in the wrong place. Knowing canonical thats completely possible. Theres also a lot of AMDGPU changes going through the pipes so it’ll be a little rough for a bit I think. Not too long, about a week.

3 Likes

Well I bought a NVME SDD to put Ubutntu 17.10 back on. No real reason a current AMD card cant game and lets see how it goes over the next few years.

I mean the major games I play is Skyrim AKA 2011 Windows game and Civ V witch is on linux as working still. So I am still tried to windows for sky rim and half a million mods.

For all this talk of Linux gaming being a pain in the ass, I have had minimal issues since 2012. However I game less these days than ever, so I am probably not as angsty about this as others may be.

2 Likes

I got pissed ok a few times…I upgraded my GTX670 to an AMD RX480 and basically did not know divinity original sin was Nvidia only . My bad and burnt. Then I have been playing xcom2 long war and it stopped working.

Lets says I buy shit gaming cards and now Im back on cool aid ububtu and XCOM is working again.

Nothing to see here move on.

P>S I dont think War for the Overworld will ever work again. I loved dungeon keeper and well I guess I cant play WFtO ever again on Linux. Money well spent :slight_smile:

I was pretty happy with my RX480. I think Mesa has come a long way.

For sure cheating here and setting up a window’s vm for gaming. >:D

I’ve been burnt quite a few times because I switched to AMD and use Linux. I fell for the hype surrounding AMD because they are open sourcing some of their driver (though a lot of features are still locked behind AMDGPU-PRO) and people insisted it was going to very quickly improve and be wonderful. It’s been trash. It was nearly a year before I got even reasonable performance out of my 390X, and even still there are games that just don’t work, or run like complete ass on AMD hardware. My next card will be Nvidia for sure. Proprietary or not, at least it actually works.

  1. If you are using a supported distro everything runs smoothly. If you are using a non-supported on well you do it accepting the risk of having some issues. Every ubuntu-based distro, debian, SteamOS, Solus and Manjaro has official support. If you do not want the risk choose ones of those. You choose Fedora a bleeding-edge distro not made for gaming. Even though it works fine from most of the time you cannot complain for having issues. The correct problem requires the correct tool.

  2. Also the AMD open drivers work flawlessly. The ¨only Nvidia support¨ thing was only for games that at the time they were developed the AMD drivers were at a transitional period and since devs had nothing to work with on the AMD side they gave no support. All developers now support both Nvidia and MESA drivers.

  3. D:OS is s special case that was developed at the time that a working AMD driver (thus was nvidia only) did not exist and they lost their Linux developer at the time thus were unable to provide any Linux support. Thats why it has issues. But there is a very quick fix for it that they themselves tell you about in their forums.

  4. Also on which universe does other OS support last forever? Running windows XP games that are not maintained any more is an equal nightmare. And if there was no GOG most games older than 2006 would not be playable.

2 Likes

They gone downhill though on the driver side of things lately while AMD has been upping their game almost continuously, the R9 390/X has a firmware problem with Linux as well as the R7 370, but my R7 360 was working fine. So the hype was real, although I never really was THAT hyped, I am just hyped to stay away from the nightmare that is fglrx.