iOS vs. Android - an Unbiased Comparison

iOS is a simple OS for the user who enjoys using simple devices.  Android is a complex OS for a user who enjoys using complex devices.

 


   iPhones have everything sealed up, so it's very easy (and expensive) if you break it; you generally just throw it out and buy a new one.

   Android phones (well, most Androids) have more modular and expandable hardware, and usually last longer.  You can usually add more memory in an SD card and carry a spare battery in case yours dies after heavy usage, among other things.


   With every iOS update, each software update (iOS and some application updates) is progressively more (very slightly with each update) hardware demanding, making you want the latest and fastest device.  Their devices have CPU's that are actually underclocked, so although they run slower in games, it increases battery life and reduces the release of heat.

   Android doesn't update quite as often, but has much faster devices than the iPhones and iPods/iPads (The Samsung Galaxy S5 has a quad-core 2.5 GHz CPU with 2GB of RAM, while the iPhone 5S has a dual-core 1.3 GHz CPU with 1GB of RAM).  This major speed difference is absolutely not true for every Android device, but it is definitely noteable.


   iOS devices are able to be Jailbroken, and although I do not know much about jailbreaking, I do believe that you cannot physically wipe the internal storage and install your own custom ROM.  Jailbroken iOS is highly customizable, however, and from what I've heard, every app on the app store is free!

   Android devices have a similar option to Jailbreaking, called Rooting your device.  Rooting is much more customizable than Jailbreaking, and you are able to install custom ROMs and, in many cases, overclock your CPU and GPU.  I am not sure if all of the Applications are free when Rooted.


On iOS, you are limited to getting apps directly from the iTunes app store.

On Android, you have the option to enable the use of third-party apps downloaded from the web or your computer.


iOS has Airplay.

Android has many alternatives that are built-in, such as NFC (for transferring files only), DLNA over WiFi.  (Airplay uses a very locked-down version of DLNA.)
Both platforms have apps from the app stores that also stream music/video/pictures between devices.


iOS has Siri, which has more feedback voice than Android.  I have heard rumors that it will soon be turned on by using a voice command such as "Hey Siri" or "Siri, *insert your request here*."  It also has some smooth, flowing transitions, which match the feel of iOS 7.

Android has Google Now, which (on most phones) can be activated with the screen turned off, in the home screen, and in the app itself, by using the voice command "Okay Google."  Google now gives a ton of location-based stats, such as reminding you to get trash bags once you enter Walmart, or only waking you up with an alarm at a certain location/area.

 


Random perks of each platform:

----iOS 7: Lots of animations, transitions, blur effects, transparency, and overall pretty appearance.  Ability to turn off or on animations.  Some animated wallpapers.  All-in-one, sealed devices that are very simple and decently durable.  Amazing hardware audio quality on pretty much all of the iOS devices.  iOS updates frequently.  There is that cool slow-motion 120FPS mode on the camera, which works great and is a lot of fun.  The lightning charger/data USB plug can be plugged in upside-down or upside-up, and is decently fast thanks to USB 2.0.  Headphones with built-in Mic1 or Mic3 work nearly flawlessly with the software.  The music application is very comprehensive and simple, yet extremely usable in terms of playlists, podcasts and many other common things.  There is an equalizer for the Music app, but you are limited to the presets that Apple gives you unless you download an app that plays music on its own.  The control center (when swiping from off-screen from the bottom up) is great and very useful!  The notification panel is just like any other, however, and gives you app notifications, weather updates, sports updates, and some other stuff.  You are limited to the iTunes store for downloading music, and I do know that there are some apps that can download music for free, but those apps don't store the music in a place that the regular iOS Music app can see and use them without jailbreaking.  You are able to plug your device into a computer, and through iTunes, you can drag and drop your songs from your music library on your computer (That means any compatible MP3, aac, etc. file on your computer) to your device.  This isn't exactly something you can do on the fly, like at a comp out or something, but it is easy if you have a computer to access!


----Android 4.4.2 KitKat:  Several variants of the OS based on phone manufacturer and carrier, such as stock KitKat, TouchWiz KitKat (Samsung), and some others.  Some transitions that are smooth but not as flowing and loose- and relaxed-feeling as iOS 7.  Transitions are somewhat customizable via Developer Settings.  Live wallpapers have been a thing with Android for a long time.  On-screen controls that rotate with the screen (when screen rotation is enabled) are common.  Some devices do have touch-based hardware buttons with a push-button home button.  Custom keyboards, such as Swype, can be installed and customized.  Little easter eggs (such as Bean Flinger, which was in Android Jelly Bean).  Some newer devices use ultra-fast USB 3.0 mini, although it is not very common yet.  The hardware sound quality varies between different devices, but is usually very good - the Adapt Sound feature helps the quality a lot though in most cases if sound quality is low.  It isn't usually quite as good in terms of quiet music playing (Lots of electronic noise can be heard at the lowest sound levels) as compared to iPods and iPhones.  The music app has a built-in Equalizer, but along with the EQ presets, you can customize EQ your own way if you wish.  The Equalizer also has something called "Soundalive," which features virtual surround, bass boost, clarity enhancer, and reverb/echo settings, and all of the previous features can be adjusted or turned off.  Android has a control center type thing in the notifications panel.  Android also features a task manager very similar to the task manager in Windows, where you can clear out the RAM to make the phone run faster, end frozen or unresponsive applications, view the applications on your phone, and many, many more things.  On the home screen, widgets are very useful tools, and there are probably as many widgets available as there are applications!  You can download music for free off of the internet, and you are not limited to a store like iTunes or Google Play for getting music.  You do not need to connect to a computer to put music onto your device, but you are certainly able to do so if you wish.


I hope that this gives you all a better understanding to the pros and cons of iOS and Android.  I own and absolutely love a Samsung Galaxy S4 Mini, and I am usually biased towards Android, but I hope that I was able to be very unbiased in this blog.  I apologize if I was biased (let me know if I was), and please don't start another war about this in the comments!  Thank you for reading!


~Corbin Blanchard, owner of Nibroc99 Productions

Great little explanation.  I like how you didn't necessarily say that one is better than the other.  They both have their benefits and disadvantages.  IMO i've gone through a lot of phones and i personally prefer the iPhone over Android.  My reason is because of how well everything just works without crashing so often as it did with my prior android phones.  Though i do miss the modding portion which is missing with Apple.  I loved putting on custom brew and even programming my own ROM's.  I may switch to android once Android L arrives, probably a Nexus 5 or wait for their next version to arrive, I've had more success and stability with the Google flagship phones over other manufacturers. 

when you jailbreak every app isnt free, but you have the option to steal it. It just lets you side load apps from repositorys. you can do all functions a jailbroken apple device does on a non rooted android. Root acess is just deeper level hardware acess which isnt all what lets you put a new rom on. Infact its just like having a normal and admin user account on a pc. Custom roms has to do with how the devices firmware allows flashing to its nand. like a nook color requires no root. you can copy android 4 to your sd card and instantly install a custom rom no rooting it doesnt even have to be set up! You might want to do a bit of research and clear a few bits up!

Android is the shit!

I personally used both iOS and Android and I have to say I slipped right into Android, I liked the look, feel, and freedom of the system and of course the price. iOS seems to be perfect for people that like a more slim  refined look without having to tweak each little setting. The main thing that bugged me about iOS was how locked down it was, took me forever to get used to it. Of course it's good to have multiple options as we have multiple people with different tastes. 

 

Just don't force your opinion fanboys and we'll be good.

Pull you're pants up >.<

I personally use android however it might be worth noting that music apps are much more readily available on the ios platform. For example jam up or bias

demonstrated here -

www.youtube.com/watch?v=5X_CeNkDiT8

www.youtube.com/watch?v=K-SEAvxqoXI

 

Equivalents do not exist on the android platform as of yet as far as I know supposedly due to latency issues but it's more likely due to the fact that ios will only ever be used on a set few hardware configurations and consequently is easier to provide a consistent user experience on.

Just a thought I had. Very well written post; no clear bias. I'm sure more will be added over time.

When I first got a real android phone (I have had a Nook Color for a few years, and that is barely even android because of how customized it is, but I still love it) I immediately felt at home.  I got the Samsung Galaxy S4 Mini at christmas of 2013, and I was instantly comfortable with where everything was, because it was right where I would have put it if I had designed the OS.

 Now, whenever I pick up my sister's iPod Touch 5, everything just feels awkward, because it's not where I would expect it to be.  I wanted to search for something on the device, and I went to swipe to the very first panel on the left (where the search used to be prior to iOS7) and I only found the first page of apps..  My sister had to tell me to swipe down to reveal the hidden search at the top.  I do really love their control panel though, because everything it just there, no hoops to jump through.  Then it took me a trial-and-error silly mistake to get to the app switcher, because I was so used to holding the home button to switch.  I ended up talking to Siri instead, haha.

So in conclusion, there's nothing wrong with iOS, it's just a very different atmosphere and takes a different mindset to use it.  I, too, didn't like how locked-down it was.  I have my own iPod Touch 4, and I was very confused as to why I couldn't install the latest update.  Nowadays, on my S4 Mini, although I had to wait for Verizon (My mom is paying for it - and she swapped me over to Verizon because it was easier (but more expensive) for her - and I flipping hate Verizon!  I take what I get, but come on, I get two bars at most everywhere I go!  Ugh, I want AT&T back!  It's like those red areas on their coverage maps are what they DON'T cover...) I had to wait for Verizon to release their version of Android 4.4.2 Kit Kat to their phones, but at least I was still able to update.  If it was because of the hardware that they couldn't release iOS7 to the iPod 4, then optimise it for the older device!  Remove some animations!  Okay, I'm done ranting, sorry about that.  XD

I do agree that music apps are much more readily available.  I mean, think of what the iPod was originally intended to be:  Not a gaming device, not a social media selfie-taking device, but a music player.  So if anything, I would expect iOS to have more music stuff.

I recently got Milk Music, which is similar to Pandora (I have Pandora too) and I personally like Milk better than Pandora or iTunes radio simply because you don't need to go through a bunch of songs for it to figure out what you like; It still tries to find out what you like by disliking or favoriting music, but there are also sliders for new/old, popular/unpopular, and more of your favorited songs/less of your faves.  I still use my iPod Touch 4 for most music, though.  I have 879 songs on it right now.  I paid for about three of them :P

Anyway, it's definitely easier to create a consistent user experience and GUI across different apps on iOS than on Android.  I agree with you about your reasoning about why that is as well.  The software was built for their specific hardware, and vice versa.

    --That cover of Dark Horse is pretty awesome too.  I never really liked the original version.  XD

The ability to have a spare battery is a must for me. I go to a music festival once a year or so and the ability to just swap the battery instead of figuring out more complicated charging solutions is an absolute necessity for me.

I've never had much experience with iOS, but maybe the jailbroken version might not be that bad. I couldn't use a non-rooted Android, as I rely on far too many apps that require root access.

I'm not entirely sure how people manage without the hardware Menu and Back buttons though. Everything seems to take extra steps.

Huh i'll have to check out milk music, sounds pretty good. :) For music I just tend to use google play music (oh the horror!) with an EQ app. I must admit I miss having a seperate music player mostly due to battery life. Using my s3 mini for music is a bit of strain on the battery. A shame really. 

 

-- Me neither! He did a cover of wrecking ball as well with a female vocalist. Worth checking out if you liked the guitar in this!

Yeah, that menu button (I call it right-click) and the back button are an absolute must for me.  I'd love to have a spare buttery, but I don't have one and I don't feel like buying one due to my laziness.

That's interesting, I hadn't thought of that use for a spare battery. Are external power banks too much hassle? Just interested in the line of thought is all.

Well, with a spare battery, it's a helluva lot quicker to switch it out rather than charge a dead battery for an hour or whatever.  Plus you don't need to have a wall outlet or a car outlet to swap a battery, so I'm sold on that.

Milk is only on Android as far as I know, and you need a Samsung account to listen to songs they call "Explicit," but aside from that there are no real requirements.  Here's a commercial for it, ignore the song choice if you don't like it, because they use the whole fucking Play store, so you don't need to deal with songs you don't like if you just change the station or press the button that says "Never play this song again." It's pretty awesome.  No ads either, aside from the occasional 2-second clip of "You're listening to Milk Music."

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hlb2zTbC5Pg

 

--I'll check that out.  Sounds awesome.

External power banks were not quite as common back when I was buying my first smartphone, Galaxy S2. I was running a lot of emulated games on that, so having a spare battery with a battery charging dock was a must. The thing was literally draining battery so fast, that it would continue running out when connected to the charger. By the time the phone ran out, the spare would've nearly charged.

I also had a lot of experience with batteries that can't hold half the charge a year from the time you purchased the device. I know for a fact that reliable rechargeable batteries exist, so not putting those in every device worth over 100$ must've been done on purpose. I'm not saying shoddy batteries are used in phones... But I don't want to bet 500$ something on that either.

Logan was showing a lot of pretty cool power banks in his videos. They're also more versatile. It might totally be an option, but should I be leaving my phone unattended to charge if it dies at the wrong time? Top up overnight - maybe. But it's also a lot more tempting to steal one of those, when going through a random person's tent, than a used battery for a phone you don't even own.

I was thinking along the lines of charge the power banks before you go and then leave your phone plugged into the power bank when you're not at a show as it were. The spare battery route does make sense though.

The theft point is most certainly valid.Thanks for pointing that out. It certainly is a shame we haven't had any recent breakthroughs in battery technology.

Turns out Milk music is exclusive to the US. :( It's a shame as it looks like my kind of thing. I tend to use spotify and click on mood playlists to find music but this looked even more simplistic and more functional. Ah well at least in the UK we have the NHS or something... *searches for benefits of the UK* Also crumpets and tea. 

Actually realized one advantage of iPhone just now. Although I would personally prefer as large a screen as I could fit in my pocket, the standard size of iPhones makes it possible do design custom hardware that works with every device.  Logan was showing an attachable gamepad that also works as a battery expansion in one of those exhibitions. Can't do that with Android, unfortunately.

I'm not struggling, being able to use a wireless PS3 compatible controller, but the compactness of that thing was quite appealing.