In the pursuit of a perfect case

Cases suck. I don't just mean airflow. We've all had "that one" case we had to use because we didn't have anything else and we hated it. And at least some of us have had that "ultimate" case that we actually got frustrated at for having a glaring imperfection. Every case was made with one or a few different users in mind and because of diverse needs and interests, no case can do everything for everybody.

In this thread, I'd like to start a discussion on case design for two main reasons: 1, I've decided to actually design my own case and find some brand that will make it for me because I'm so frustrated with the current market and no case will be what I really want and 2, I'd like the opinions of you guys because I may not think of things that I should. Plus, I just want to see what works of art you nerds have going on.

Specifically, I'd like to discuss what a case should be/have in general as well as what variations would be taken to meet specific needs. What I mean by in general is that someone might say that "oh, every computer should have at least two CD drive bays because xyz" which would be perfectly fine, unless you are talking about a micro build meant to be portable. Hopefully you see what I mean by "every case should or have this this this" while keeping in mind the form factor. For simplicity, let's just say mini (portable kind of mini), average ATX, and enthusiast level huge.

Below, I'll make a second post explaining my current rig and where I'd like to go. Seriously, I will be designing my own case after this and if anybody knows where I can get such a thing made, please let me know.

Right now, I am using the Raidmax Agusta. This case was kind of the catalyst to get me wanting to design one because it showed me so many things that I like while also having some glaring problems that I think no case should ever have.

Here's a link in case you don't know the case:
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16811156284

Keep in mind that most things are subjective to personal taste as well as specific needs.
Pros:
1.I love gawdy, flamboyant, flashy hardware. The angular, boxy look as well as door on the front, LED, etc, is a look I've always loved in a computer.
2.The number and location of CD drive bays are very functional. You could design a build in a number of ways around them. Tool-less design is always nice.
3.Good, well positioned USB access on top as well as build in fan/LED control.
4.The bottom chamber that holds all the SSDs/HDDs and has it's own air flow is a great design, both functionally (in theory, see below for downside) and aesthetically.
5.Plenty of fan spaces for great airflow (there's actually a downside to this, said below)
6.This case is amazing for watercooling*

Cons:
1.Getting the back plate on this case while doing cable management is... absolutely... terrible... Why, why, WHY is almost every case I see made with a backplate that hugs the case where all the wires are????
2.This case has negative air pressure by default, meaning dust collects on the backside and any other significant opening. There's little to do to fix this because...
3.The power and SATA cable routing to the bottom channel that holds the storage is placed at a terrible spot, right over where a drive would be. And the backside of the channel doesn't have enough room (just like the backplate...) meaning you have to route cables very intuitively. If you have a completely modular PSU where you don't have SATA power connections every few inches on a single strip, this is less of an issue since you aren't trying to cramp 4-6 inches of wire between connections in a 1.5 inch gap between drives.
4.The construction is a little flimsy as it is covered in several places in plastic.
5.This case it typically negative pressured
6.This case is at the same time terrible for water cooling*

*I have put a CD drive and a multi-card reader in the top 2 of 3 CD bays and put a pump+res in the bottom two bays. I then routed tubing from there to the GPU, then to the outside of the case where I ghetto mounted a small, 80mm rad to the back of the storage chamber, making use of the airflow the case already had and not having to buy any new fans. The tubing then goes back in to the pump+res. I could add another rad on the intake fan in the front, aiding GPU cooling but making CPU cooling a bit worse. The top of the case is designed in an odd way where you couldn't fit a rad with fans on it while using an aftermarket air CPU cooler unless it was low profile. I assume the case was designed with a standard CPU water cooling kit in mind. if I were desperate, I could put a 140mm rad on the exhaust port in the back. That would aid GPU cooling and help make the case more positive pressure by impeding exhaust.

For an example of another case I like but still have issues with, see the Azza GT1 and ask if you are curious what I like about said case.

Thoughts, comments? Again, anybody who knows a fully custom case maker, say so!

IMO, a case with a cup holder would be fecking fantastic.

If you're looking for what the tek syndicate forummers are into collectively:
https://forum.teksyndicate.com/t/your-favorite-case-and-why/72784

https://forum.teksyndicate.com/t/most-beautiful-cases-ever-made/79437/1

Also, this happened a while ago too, may be of interest. Someone did a survey on case design (they were and may still be designing a series of cases for a project of theirs):
https://forum.teksyndicate.com/t/does-anyone-mind-completing-a-quick-survey-on-pc-case-design/79105

I just want a case that looks like something out of a mad scientists laboratory, or has a cyber punk feel to it.

1 Like

Huh, thanks for the links. Funny how I only saw the "Most beautiful case..." thread while searching for similar threads before I made this one.

What case it this? Functionally, it looks like something I might be interested in but externally it's a bit too boring for me.

BeQuiet! Silent Base 800

This Case.... every day of the week

Proof: https://youtu.be/yg7DPighyk4?list=LLom8_hrEQvhsnw4uv5vrJyA

In my opinion, Lian Li, with their huge catalog has something for everyone as far as aesthetics go (they have trains and seashells for shit's sake). Functionality, usability, and design quality is always the question though.

InWin makes some great looking cases, but many dont rate very high on usability.

CaseLabs cases are great and are awesome quality, but aesthetically might be a bit boring if you dont like the clean/minimal design.

Silverstone makes solid cases (mostly) too, but once again they lean towards the clean aesthetic.

Wtf did I just watch... give me about 9 more hours to decide how I feel about this XD

1 Like

ITS A LEFTY! Very interesting, or is that just a flipped image? Probably just a flipped image.

silverstone, i think it's like that.

Ah yes they do like a little bit of that now and then don't they.

If you are referring to the case I mentioned, it's reversable. And Silverstone also does lefties

SpaceCat you wish is my command :D.

http://www.tigerdirect.com/applications/SearchTools/item-details.asp?EdpNo=1104463

Remenber seeing this a while ago cup holder and ciggi lighter ftw :D.

I'm actually building my case at the moment from scratch. Then I'm just going to get it fabricated myself (just send my designs to a CNC cutting/bending company).

Sadly it seems very few cases are designed for a single reason and most are designed just to be a box which is just silly as then it never really fits anyone's needs. Along with poor airflow designs, awkward maintenance, I decided to make my own.

Things I think are a must if your building your own case.
140mm Fans rather than 120mm (you might as well considering your designing the case and 2cm isn't much).

Easily removable side panel: this is just a given, but if your gonna build your own case you really need to figure out your own locking mechanism for the side panels without just screwing the side panel directly to the case.

To watercool or not: This is just a general question but you really need to think which you will use, as cases have to change dramatically if you need to fit WC stuff inside at some point. So my golden rule in design is don't try to make it work for both or otherwise it just won't fit both either.

Design the case specifically with a certain size board in mind: If your going custom design why not make it perfectly fit a ATX and have the cables placed specifically with that size in mind, not have it kinda fit 3 different sizes of boards.

Allow cables to be hidden behind the motherboard try: This is quite obvious to all us but does seem to be something cases miss most of the time, as most have very little room behind the tray so you end up making your case look horrible inside.

I saw these before, they're discontinued. ,_,

Cup holders existed??? And are gone??? What is this, the stone age?? Come on people!

Anyway, I completely agree with you. Even my Raidmax Agusta, for all the things I love about this case, it's just... it's bad, it really is. Like every other case I've loved. If you know a company I can start working with to build a case, please lemme know. I'm going to build a monster. I'm thinking of making a wall mount too...

I have been thinking about making my own case as well..I have this desk http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00166HC9E/?tag=teksynd-20..I do not use the keyboard tray so I am thinking of making a aluminum drawer..That will fit in that space It will have more height than the tray, this would make my desk kinda of like the lian desk cases http://www.lian-li.com/en/files/2014/05/dkq1-main-b.jpg ..I just need to collect enough aluminum to melt down, and brass for a polished motherboard tray (also need some molding sand)..It is gonna be time to put my 50$ forge to work..I act like I hate my CM storm trooper case, but really it is more about space and how to use it efficiently..I hope to have this project done by the end of the year..If you are looking to make your own case you may want to look into aluminum casting and maybe a brake drum forge then make the case yourself..

P.S. I have never done anything like this before so it is gonna be fun..I wonder if I will fail and if I do how long will it take for me to get it right..

Yea I even have a Lian Li V2110B which is an absolute beast, and yet it still has more problems than you can shake a stick at (nowhere to route the cables for example bloody annoying). Currently making a scratch build of my Bitfenix Phenom

Tek what's country you living in ? If it's the UK your literally smothered by the amount available, I literally googled CNC fabrication/ cutting, things like that into google, and got a wealth of them (literally 5 companies who can do the work in just my small area). Best ones to look for are ones that have CNC/laser cutting and CNC Bending as you'll be able to produce a really clean looking case.

Currently going to be using a fabrication company called "freshlook". If you want the best results to find these companies look on Yell etc as they tend to either not have a very good website or none at all. But look for them online by using things like "CNC fabrication companies" etc and for finishing a piece look for "metal finishers" etc.