Did some traveling recently, and while in a different country where my cell service did not work, I realized I could not access my email (and other a few other services).
This made it impossible to check in for flights online. It also caused a couple other email related issues during my trip eg: couldn’t access email confirmations, couldn’t check reservation times…
I hate SMS based 2FA. I already disliked it before, but after this experience of being completely locked out of my own accounts, I will never willingly sign up for SMS based 2FA ever again, for any service. But here is the second issue, keyword willingly. Some services offer SMS as the only 2FA option, and worse yet, force it’s use at time of sign up. I hate this even more.
It begs the question; is it even optional to own a phone in the modern world? As android gets worse year over year turning into iOS, I find myself not even wanting to own a phone anymore. Those who manage to not have a cell phone, how do you navigate the web or even IRL services that ask for a phone number?
It seems even some online games now require SMS verification. It’s not for security. It’s for perverted data brokers. It’s a yet another violation of privacy in the ever growing list.
I remember complaining to my bank for years to add 2FA before they had any, and when they finally did, of course they only offer SMS…
the worst possible option.
I will be now be removing SMS from all accounts that allow me to (hint, most don’t allow removing after adding, which is also awful).
Even Github warns against SMS based 2FA.
![]()
I am pro 2FA, but I would rather have no 2FA than have a dependency on SMS.
TOTP (Time-based one-time password) is objectively better in every conceivable way. Unlike SMS, a time based one time password:
- isn’t susceptible to sim swapping / cell interception attacks
- doesn’t rely on any 3rd party services, or having cell reception (no dependencies)
- preserves privacy
- open source implementation in many password managers
- free


