I loathe SMS based MFA & forced apps (rant)

Did some traveling recently, and while in a different country where my cell service did not work, I realized I could not access my email (and other a few other services).

This made it impossible to check in for flights online. It also caused a couple other email related issues during my trip eg: couldn’t access email confirmations, couldn’t check reservation times…

I hate SMS based 2FA. I already disliked it before, but after this experience of being completely locked out of my own accounts, I will never willingly sign up for SMS based 2FA ever again, for any service. But here is the second issue, keyword willingly. Some services offer SMS as the only 2FA option, and worse yet, force it’s use at time of sign up. I hate this even more.

It begs the question; is it even optional to own a phone in the modern world? As android gets worse year over year turning into iOS, I find myself not even wanting to own a phone anymore. Those who manage to not have a cell phone, how do you navigate the web or even IRL services that ask for a phone number?

It seems even some online games now require SMS verification. It’s not for security. It’s for perverted data brokers. It’s a yet another violation of privacy in the ever growing list.

I remember complaining to my bank for years to add 2FA before they had any, and when they finally did, of course they only offer SMS… :frowning: the worst possible option.

I will be now be removing SMS from all accounts that allow me to (hint, most don’t allow removing after adding, which is also awful).

Even Github warns against SMS based 2FA.

image


I am pro 2FA, but I would rather have no 2FA than have a dependency on SMS.

TOTP (Time-based one-time password) is objectively better in every conceivable way. Unlike SMS, a time based one time password:

  • isn’t susceptible to sim swapping / cell interception attacks
  • doesn’t rely on any 3rd party services, or having cell reception (no dependencies)
  • preserves privacy
  • open source implementation in many password managers
  • free
4 Likes

Thanks for the insight.

What is TOTP?

Off to Goggle it…

As I am sure you have already searched by now, but I have updated OP to include the fully spelled out non-abbreviation of TOTP, and will copy pasta a definition here for quick reference for others:

>Time-based one-time password (TOTP) is a computer algorithm that generates a one-time password (OTP) using the current time as a source of uniqueness. As an extension of the HMAC-based one-time password (HOTP) algorithm, it has been adopted as Internet Engineering Task Force (IETF) standard RFC 6238.[1]

–

If you would like to try it out, you will find that even this very forum supports it under Profile > Preferences > Security > Two-Factor Authentication

Once in there you can add a ‘Token-Based Authenticators’ and use either the QR or copy paste the code manually into your password manager of choice.

For example Aegis is a great password manager and has TOTP/HOTP support.

2 Likes

I’m not a fan of SMS-based 2FA either… I recently had an unpleasant experience when my bank suddenly decided to change my 2FA to SMS without my knowledge or consent… I had a surprise when I tried to log in. Luckily, I had the number on me, because it would have been a disaster. :confused:

As for accessing the text messages themselves, you can always leave your phone at home, which will have the phone number, and Macrodroid with a macro that, upon receiving the text message, will forward it, for example, via email. Of course, as long as you have internet access. :slight_smile:

1 Like

Between SMS and emailing a passcode I’d rather SMS. I’ve a scattering of a few accounts that use auth apps and, so far, two which support passkeys. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

1 Like

No. I learned this 20 years ago when I tried to rent a car for a weekend trip and was told I would need to provide TWO phone numbers before they would complete the transaction.

If you think you can function without a phone today, try again.

A lot of people are up in arms about age verification. That was sealed shut long ago. SSO accounts nowadays require 2FA authentication through SMS (as you mentioned) or another means to provide for multiple means for authentication.

Guess what’s tied to your phone number? Your name. Your date of birth. Your SSN. I can go on.

It won’t be long before “burner” phones are a thing of the past.

2 Likes

And another thing that annoys me about forced 2FA / MFA is garbage proprietary authenticator apps.

No, I will not be installing Microsoft Authenticator on my personal phone as my work requires. Luckily I have one of their dev devices I use specifically for that. If I didn’t have that I would require a separate work phone, provided by them.

I need the physical and digital separation of work and home. No BYOD for me, thanks.

No, you don’t get to run google analytics, firebase cancer, ask for 32+ permissions on my personal device just to log in. It’s an absurd ask.


MFA is a good thing. But forcing shitty MFA systems on us is not good. Just another data harvesting mechanism under the excuse of security.

2 Likes

This is becoming increasingly frustrating as I age.

When I grew up, owning a phone was optional. It was even a privilege. I am old enough that I didn’t have a phone until after highschool. Now it is mandatory to own a phone. And it happened so fast…

This is growing unacceptable. I feel like my digital rights are being infringed upon. Not that digital rights exist, or are respected by anyone. But it is clearly a growing problem that is not being addressed.

Am I just an old man yelling at clouds? Sometimes I feel like I am beginning to lose my mind. Screaming into a void. No one ever listens.

2 Likes

Your link hangs half way for me. Or I have a short attention span…

¯\_(ツ)_/¯

1 Like

This really grinds my gear because microslop has a dark pattern where you can add another authentication app, but the microslop version is first and made to appear as the only option.

I don’t trust microslop to have invasive monitoring

With copilot it is now even easier to track and process chats.
https://cybernews.com/tech/microsoft-teams-snitch-location-office-boss/

If they are so brazen about this I don’t trust what they do in my phone

Tho I dislike any corporate MFAs that force you to install a app

1 Like

Sorry to hijack your thread but, had a question

I got a couple yubikeys, so I can MFA

But, I used hotmail for some stuff.

Microsoft failed to allow yubikeys as a hardware token, storing a passkey or anything, so I kinda shelved them

I don’t suppose not MS are doing the whole 365 thing, if anyone knows whether yubikeys work for MS accounts on Linux?

Just with Firefox, not looking to install edge, logged in to a Microsoft account

I really had hoped it would work widely as a second factor, but was dissapointed, tbh

I don’t consider it a hijack. Consider this a place to rant about bad, or poorly implemented MFA in general.

As to your question tho, I have no answer. As my work environment is still held hostage in the windows ecosystem. Perhaps someone else knows.

1 Like

Yeah. this is already a lost battle by simply using windows.

https://sizeof.cat/post/windows-telemetry/

I tolerate it because its a work machine and it is managed by my employer.

I simply do not mix personal and work machines, and I will not install teams or anything like that on my personal devices. That is a hard boundary.

Agreed. Hard pass. If they need me to install an app, it gets installed on their device. Not mine.

1 Like

Maybe this solution will be more compatible… :confused:

1 Like

Still relies in MS allowing a passkey/fido token to be used on Linux.

That didn’t work when I tried before, I was hoping someone may know it does work, before I set IP the hardware key, rather than have to go back and remove it

The least time I spend on windows, the happier I am, thb

1 Like

Amen. :folded_hands:

1 Like


Saw this meme and was reminded of this thread

1 Like

I had a similar issue when i worked in IT, I had to install a whopping dozen or so auth apps or other assorted trash. We were working for different clients so every vpn needed some mfa app and only the bigger ones consolidated all under a microslop account.

Android has a function that lets an employer provision a sandbox in your phone where the apps inside cannot see outside and apps outside cannot see inside. So it allows BYOD with more privacy and control. Android work profile.

This function can be provisioned and operated on your own too if you use the opensource app Shelter

I used it in my previous job for the mfas and teams and whatnot, and still use it now to sandbox the bs apps (ebay aliexpress and friends).

2 Likes

+1 for shelter, much more convenient than switching android profiles

1 Like