When talking cars, there is a simple formula I like to go by in regards to reliability: K.I.S.S.
Seriously, I'm generally not a fan of newer cars as manufactures have piled on more and more useless crap, and yes, I am even talking about safety features. Remember how everyone says Honda and Toyota are super reliable? This was a thing from back in the 80's and 90's when they built REALLY simple cars. Like power steering and AC were not available simple. When there is less on the car, there is less to go wrong.
Translate this to modern cars, and here is where you are at: CVT is shit. Autos are shit. All that extra climate controlled electronics are shit. Stupidly overly complicated entertainment /NAV system is shit. Airbags are shit. Traction control is shit. I'm saying all this because as far as the cars you have picked out, there is honestly not a damn difference between them. Go ahead and throw a Malibu and Camry in there as well, because it REALLY doesn't matter. Navigation systems in cars are stupidly outdated, slow, and just don't work well. Touchscreens DON'T belong in cars. Auto climate control systems tend to have some sort of failure after 10-15 years. Backup cameras are a poor excuse to prevent you from properly being aware of your surroundings. Bluetooth in cars (ESPECIALLY pre-2010 era) tend to royally suck, and not work properly with 99% of phones out there (remember, this was pre-smartphone era). Airbag systems have major recalls all the damn time (not just this most recent disaster), traction control provides a STUPID false sense of security for those who do not know how to properly handle their vehicle. Automatic transmissions seem to always fail on most vehicles after 200k miles, and CVT at half that.
With all that said, hold on for just a minute, and I'll try and guide you on where I'm going with this.
My point here is that usually when I see people asking what car to buy, they want someone to come forward and say 'Oh, car A has major xxx problems. Car B and C are super reliable' without citing a damn bit of evidence to back up their claim. It is literally based on maybe a few cars they personally owned, or hell, maybe even heard about someone owning. Simply put, its a recommendation based on nothing more than how they feel.
So HERE is what I recommend
Buy whatever the hell you want. Seriously, just find something you LOVE, that speaks to you. Beyond something like a 25 year old $2000 car you spend $3000 on maintenance on to be reliable, EVERYTHING else is fluff, so think about what fluff makes you happy! What crap makes you want to hop in the car at 10 at night to go for a drive to de-stress. What car out there are you OK with spending money on when something breaks because you love it so much, and that you WANT to hold onto for the next 20+ years, possible till the day you die.
If you can not fathom that kind of attachment to a car, then why the hell are you spending $6000 on pieces of shit like those. I get it, loving cars isn't for everyone, but for the love of God, don't waste your money on something you don't love that much and are likely to sell in the next 5 years. Go shopping and just search for the best damn deal on whatever piece of shit you find. No sense in asking the lords of the internet for their wise knowledge, because IT WONT HELP YOU. They can not see the condition of those cars. They can not tell you how well they were taken care of mechanically. The most reliable car brand/model can be a worse purchase than even Hyundai/Kia crap just due to how well it was cared for. So, just shop around, find some good deals on some stuff that looks decent to you, and above all.....
GET A PRE-PURCHASE INSPECTION DONE ON EACH ONE!
