I think I see at least these factors in my decision not to get a Librem 5,
- DDR PHY issue — the code to train the DDR PHY is proprietary; Purism uses this but runs it on an separate CPU core to claim the “secondary processor” loophole in the FSF RYF certification. This pointlessly complicates things, without any real security benefit that I can tell. Marcan (of console-hacking fame) explains this fairly well on Twitter.
See also: Phoronix article, Purism post about their RYF workaround. - I too have read the Phoronix interview that @SesameStreetThug references
- Suspicion around marketing wording and prices, similar to what @Eden mentioned.
I see it as these points affecting how much I am willing to trust Purism. In purchase decisions, this trust affects how much of a premium I am willing to overpay. For a substantially less capable phone, with more limited cellular band support than my current one, a Librem 5 is not worth it to me.
The hardware kill switches and more-standard Linux support are the only real points in its favour for me. I do however, think it will have a positive impact on the KDE, GNOME, and Ubuntu Touch upstream, and for that I am glad that it exists (thanks @imhigh.today
).
Since I am finding it interesting to try to explain my thinking here, I will go on a brief tangent about their laptops (Librem 13/15):
Here I am quite seriously considering a purchase if there is a clearance sale for the v4 revision (as there was for v3). The builtin kill switch for the camera and more importantly microphone is definitely a draw; especially as a mechanism someone else has already tested, rather than a one-off homemade hack. I also like the idea of supporting a product whose development has helped improve coreboot, and is supporting work like Heads (something I was already looking into). Maybe I am misguided, but the premium for their laptops here seems more reasonable to me; I would definitely be waiting for a sale, however.
This said, in comparison to an equivalent product from System76 at a similar price, I do still find myself biased in Purism’s favour; I have more respect for a company that took a harder initial stance against proprietary firmware.
As a final note, my decision is also influenced by opportunity cost; I am willing to get a phone/laptop that is worse from an open-source/owner-control/security standpoint, if it lets me save money to afford a Blackbird POWER9 system as a desktop. It ticks more open-source “boxes” on my checklist as it were, and I trust/respect the company more than Purism.
@anon46267848 I perceive your initial post to be anticipating hypocrisy on the part of FLOSSers, which I think includes me in this case. I am genuinely curious what you think of my decision-making process here.