Dear FLOSSers, why aren't you buying this?

I think I see at least these factors in my decision not to get a Librem 5,

  • DDR PHY issue — the code to train the DDR PHY is proprietary; Purism uses this but runs it on an separate CPU core to claim the “secondary processor” loophole in the FSF RYF certification. This pointlessly complicates things, without any real security benefit that I can tell. Marcan (of console-hacking fame) explains this fairly well on Twitter.
    See also: Phoronix article, Purism post about their RYF workaround.
  • I too have read the Phoronix interview that @SesameStreetThug references
  • Suspicion around marketing wording and prices, similar to what @Eden mentioned.

I see it as these points affecting how much I am willing to trust Purism. In purchase decisions, this trust affects how much of a premium I am willing to overpay. For a substantially less capable phone, with more limited cellular band support than my current one, a Librem 5 is not worth it to me.

The hardware kill switches and more-standard Linux support are the only real points in its favour for me. I do however, think it will have a positive impact on the KDE, GNOME, and Ubuntu Touch upstream, and for that I am glad that it exists (thanks @imhigh.today :slight_smile:).


Since I am finding it interesting to try to explain my thinking here, I will go on a brief tangent about their laptops (Librem 13/15):
Here I am quite seriously considering a purchase if there is a clearance sale for the v4 revision (as there was for v3). The builtin kill switch for the camera and more importantly microphone is definitely a draw; especially as a mechanism someone else has already tested, rather than a one-off homemade hack. I also like the idea of supporting a product whose development has helped improve coreboot, and is supporting work like Heads (something I was already looking into). Maybe I am misguided, but the premium for their laptops here seems more reasonable to me; I would definitely be waiting for a sale, however.

This said, in comparison to an equivalent product from System76 at a similar price, I do still find myself biased in Purism’s favour; I have more respect for a company that took a harder initial stance against proprietary firmware.


As a final note, my decision is also influenced by opportunity cost; I am willing to get a phone/laptop that is worse from an open-source/owner-control/security standpoint, if it lets me save money to afford a Blackbird POWER9 system as a desktop. It ticks more open-source “boxes” on my checklist as it were, and I trust/respect the company more than Purism.


@anon46267848 I perceive your initial post to be anticipating hypocrisy on the part of FLOSSers, which I think includes me in this case. I am genuinely curious what you think of my decision-making process here.

3 Likes

I’m also planning to go all in with PinePhone/watch/cube and perhaps Pinebook or Tab, but I think the question honestly misses the mark COMPLETELY. We can install whatever OS we want on whatever hardware we want. Yes, locked down hardware or stuff with zero Linux drivers throws a wrench in the works for the average user, but what we really need is a badass mobile Linux OS (ideally for phones and cars) and money behind it to develop programs, drivers, and refine the UI.

The burning question isn’t what hardware, but rather what software are people going to financially support?

I guess you don’t have to like the UBPorts UI to appreciate the work that they do. I’m sure they, as well as other projects, could use some cash. There are currently only a handful of OS options for the PinePhone, but hopefully the list will grow as the hardware gets into more hands:

https://wiki.pine64.org/index.php/PinePhone#Operating_Systems

I’d really love to see something like BountySource take off. Anyone can set a new bounty for the software they want to see, or you can pitch more money in the pot of an existing bounty to make it more attractive for someone to develop. They also have a Patreon-like system to donate to specific projects. Many say they will just reinvest into more bounties.

The main problem with donations is that the higher level you go, the less likely they are to do exactly what you want, which can make someone upset over it and stop donating. It’s like trying to navigate a ship from land by yelling at it. I don’t personally know many people who can do anything positive for open source software besides give money or speak well of it. Targeting donations so they yield the changes you want to see could be more rewarding and make you more likely to donate again.

You seem like a reasonable person.

My issue is, as you no doubt have guessed, the typical people in the aforementioned communities complaining about things and making demands whilst putting down what’s available on the market.
But once it comes down to it, and they get what they were asking for in the first place, most are unwilling to deal with the consequences and compromises that is an unavoidable reality in the device they demanded, or it’s “not good enough, next please!”.

2 Likes

Nobody is buying those kind of devices because they’re basically test hardware they’re selling to customers because there isn’t a multibillion company behind it and they can’t develop and test devices on their own. I really don’t think there’s much more than that behind it.
Also, as much as someone can be loyal to their moral compass, if a tool is needed to achieve a goal it doesen’t really matter what’s behind it.

Imagine adding a case on that big bitch

1 Like

SesameStreetThug went into it for me. Purism has been sketchy from the beginning over promising and failing at most turns. I remember them making a bunch of claims about using libreboot to the point libreboot came out and said they didn’t think their stuff would be able to support it and to this day they don’t recommend purism.

The interview he posted just confirmed what a lot of us saw coming when it was posted.

1 Like

Because the Pinephone exists.

I mean, it’s a Raspberry Pi on super steroids.

Built in; WiFi, GSM, GPS, gyro, accelerometer, 2 cameras, high def touch screen, two speakers, microphone, storage, MicroSD slot, battery management circuit, battery, high power LED light, hardware kill switches for certain sensors, I2C pogo pins, and a nice and sleek case? For a measly 150 euros? To me it sounds like an incredible DIY project SBC.

If it also can serve as a daily driver phone then that’s just an added bonus.

4 Likes

Pinefone does look good.
And they did the pine64 and doing the pinebook

The pine phone is on my list to get. Good little device to hack around with. And perhaps a simple backup phone.

Librem 5, not so much.

2 Likes

I like the idea of it. I like the idea of a more freedom oriented ‘ecosystem’.

Price and user-base are decision factors for me personally. May seem superficial but I prefer not to be strapped to a phone too much when I can.

The thread definitely has me gazing into greener pastures of privacy though (may not be the best analogy).

It’s barely a proof of concept and completely unfit for real world use, as described in the Ars Technica article.

I’m not buying it because i don’t want a modular phone :smiley:

IMHO its a shit idea, as soon as you go modular, you end up with way more complexity (in terms of hardware/software complexity, assumptions about what may be in the box, etc.), for what? It’s a smartphone… just put reasonable current spec parts in it and replace when tech moves on.

Also anything removable needs a decent retention mechanism that won’t break, fall apart and/or increase the size/weight of the device and that isn’t simple.

I’d rather the device not be modular and include more powerful hardware/battery in the same physical size personally.

A lot of people think they know what they want (modular, switches, etc.) but then when someone makes it, they see the size/cost/durability/stability/complexity/weight/performance compromises and don’t want it.

What they don’t get is that those compromises are inherent to doing this - because all those retention brackets, sockets, plugs, etc. inside the thing take up space. Especially if you want them strong enough to not fall apart if you look at it funny. And that’s space you could better use for compute hardware or battery.

Battery life already sucks bad enough on non-modular devices. Don’t make it worse!

This is why design by committee (which is what this thing is) sucks a lot of the time. You end up with some non-focused pile of hot garbage (because everybody wants their pet feature) that does nothing particularly well, instead of a focused device to do a narrowly defined job as well as possible.

This sort of design is like wanting to add various contraptions like screwdriver bits, knife blades, and pliers to your typical claw-hammer. NO! It’s a hammer! You’re just going to make something shit at every job, rather than good at what it does!

1 Like

I am not buying this because it is still only a preorder item.

1 Like