Building New Workstation, Opinions?

Hey guys,

I've been using a MacPro for years but it's time to upgrade and in lieu of the trashcan I'm going to be building myself a workstation. I have a budget of about $5000 (Somewhat flexible). I've been looking around for a couple of months trying to accumulate some knowledge about the hardware world again as I've been detached from it for so long. I've come up with an idea of what I think makes the most sense for longevity and value for the budget. I will be using this machine for everything. I'm a web developer so I don't have video production needs but I do end up doing a considerable amount of multi tasking and I make heavy use of Photoshop, Fireworks and Illustrator so a machine that's a capable productivity box is a must. (I originally switched from pc to mac due to the memory leaks in older versions of creative suite on the windows side.) I would also like this box to be a competent gaming rig for 1440p but bleeding edge not required and have ample storage for media files. I have plenty of room so size isn't a constraint I would however prefer to aim for something with non deafening noise levels. I will likely do some light overclocks just to optimize the hardware but nothing too strenuous.

For those of you who don't want to read all that here's a bullet version

Requirements

  • Strong productivity, Not Editing Video
  • Photoshop, Fireworks, Illustrator in heavy use
  • Competent Gaming @ 1440p
  • Lots of Storage For Media Files
  • Quiet Operation Preferred
  • Light Overclocking

Here's where I'm at right now,

http://pcpartpicker.com/user/alexboorman/saved/3A1H

I welcome your suggestions and opinions. The one question I have been asking myself and haven't really been able to find a solid answer to is this, Is it a mistake to buy into lga2011 right now at this price point. Would I be better off waiting for the next gen of processors to drop this kind of money? I'm not rich or anything so $5000 is no small chunk of change for me.

Thanks guys, I appreciate your help.

that would be a really nice build :)

that seems like about $2,500 of overkill for what you're wanting it to do... but yea that's a badass build

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7Tyudcr1uLY This right here would be beastly.  Just a note that the case in the video is Define R4 Xl 

What about it do you feel like is overkill? Where would you cut? Anyone have any opinions on the Rampage Black vs P9X79-E WS? I don't really run any disparate pci-e cards right now so I don't think I benefit greatly from the WS class validation. I'm also not 100% on the RAM, does anyone have a good experience with running two quad channel kits that aren't validated as a 64GB kit together well?

I've definitely seen this video but I don't really want to run Xeons because I want to be able to play games also.

Who says Xeons can't play games?  In fact a believe logan is making about a certain xeon (which I don't remember) vs. the i7 4770k.  It will definitely be interesting.   

Get xeons they are great and they run just as well as the equivalent i7 you can even pay less if you get the models that don't have integrated graphics onboard

http://pcpartpicker.com/p/2KYOQ

That's what I'd build... here's why:

CPU: Haswell i7 is plenty of CPU for what you're doing and then some... overclock at will

CPU COOLER: Krakens are just beastmode... only reason NZXT stayed in business as long as they did...

MOBO: Z87 ROG mobo, can't go wrong there, and they are a lot cheaper than the x79 models...

MEMORY: 16GB  of memory will be more than enough... you won't EVER use 64GB of memory untill maybe 10 years from now... 16 GB is recommended for video editing and 3D rendering (which you aren't doing) so it's overkill anyways... plenty of clock speed and REALLY low CAS @ 8

STORAGE: Upgraded performance on your storage... the Corsair Force has a 512MB BUS (it's lightning fast) and 240GB is PLENTY of room for your OS and core programs (CS6, etc... Windows 7, CS6, Solidworks, and Mastercam all fit with comfy room to spare on my 120GB SSD... there's no reason to load games on a SSD as expensive as they are and the performance increase is only noticeable in load times) 4TB of 7200 RPM Barracuda should hold a king's media collection and be noticably faster than the 3TB 5600 RPM Caviar Green HDDs... if it's not enough, you've got an extra $2,000 for a NAS or more HDDs... but buying 9.5TB of storage off the bat is an insane amount of storage... that's enough for a 30 employee company's NAS that deals with large files... You can load your games on them and they'll play fast enough...

GPU: One EVGA 780 Classified should hold you over... try it first... if you don't think that's enough power then get the SLI, as there's room in the PSU for the upgrade... but try it first single before you blow another $530 on an extra GPU... the 780 Classy should be the best performing 780 under the 780TI (which isn't much better but is ridiculously more expensive)

CASE: Full towers are HUGE... the Fractal Design Define R4 is a bulky mid-ATX case with tons of room for everything you need... it's sleek and silent...

PSU: XFX 850w  is enough for OC and SLI should you ever go that route... good quality parts (Seasonic rebrand) and this one's gold rated and fully modular...

OPTICAL: Cheapest blu ray writer on pcpartpicker... performs fine I'm sure...

If you want to tack on case fans, feel free... but this is WAY MORE than enough CPU for what you asked for, and it's HALF the price... It will perform very similarly and will be faster loading due to the better storage... trust me... save yourself 2 grand, get this, and if you need more space buy a nice NAS or more HDDs... if 1440p isn't ultra'd out, feel free to tack on the SLI... even if you get a another NAS AND SLI you're still looking at $1000 cheaper (with a really nice NAS)

Jesus, man. What EXACTLY are you using this rig for?

Hey thanks a lot I appreciate your input. I know I can save a lot of money and buy something much cheaper that will my needs adequately but I'm used to buying systems on a mac time table. I replace every 5-6 years so I want to buy into longevity and expandability. Going into 1150 really limits me, I lose the raid controller and I'm way more limited in terms of pci-e expansion. I really like the multitude of internal sata expansion too. I'm currently running a 6TB thunderbolt external and I only have 2TB free so I really want to give myself some head room and avoid external storage as much as possible. I have a file server here but it's only sata2 so I don't really want to waste time on it until I get an opportunity to do some research on replacing the board and getting a new raid controller for it (it's linux so I have to validate compliance). Also seems like 2TB drives are a bad value for the cost, seems like 3TB is at a better price/storage ratio. I am interested in the Seagate thing though, i understood there to only be a slight hit on performance with the modern greens which is why I chose them. Lower power consumption, heat output and comparable speed, seems like a good deal for someone looking to stack a lot of drives. I'm replacing a mac pro with this so im used to a full tower case ^^, I have an eight foot long, 3.5 foot deep desk so space isnt a big deal lol. I do agree though, I'm overbuilding. I will do some reading on the Krakens and the G-Skill ram, the last time I built a computer both of those companies were making cheap junk. If they have climbed the quality ladder I'm interested. I've also considered the noctua air coolers. I just went with the closed loop for low noise. You think the corsair solid states are better than the samsung ones? I chose the samsung because almost everything I've read and watched showered praise on the samsungs.  Thanks again for your input, I really appreciate a different point of view ^^

For all of you recommending Xeons, it's my understanding that they suffer severely with no multi-threaded optimized loads, so anything that isn't optimized will not perform that well and Xeons are fully locked, I'd like to at least have the option of overclocking.

I'm really interested in the Fractal case, i like the way it looks but I don't think it will fit unless I buy an atx board.

I won't try to talk you out of a 6-core Intel then... I mean they are awesome... just seem like more of a "hey, look what I bought!" than a practical solution for the intended purpose of the computer... I used to do graphic design and my i5 did the job and then some in Photoshop, Illustrator, Dreamweaver, InDesign, Flash, and Flash Builder... It really doesn't use a lot of multi-threading... I did notice a good bit of increase when I got my GTX 780 from the CUDA acceleration...

The other mobo does support RAID, however you would need to get a RAID controller, that's true...

However, I'm not sure what you'd want to expand on with the PCIe slots... once you have 2 780s in SLI, there's little need for a third... and nothing else I'm aware of really needs a PCIe 3.0 slot... however, like I said, if you want the six-core and x79 chipset, I'm not going to talk you out of it... do note the $4,000 Mac Pro has crossfired Firepro D500 which looks to be between a 280X and 270X as far as stream processors and BUS... so if you were to crossfire them you're looking at 280X performance more or less in gaming... that means one GTX 780 will significantly outperform the Mac Pro's crossfired GPU setup... I guess my question would be what expandability would you be looking into?

5600RPM HDDs are slower than 7200RPM HDDs... especially when gaming... I might at least buy one Barracuda and load games and whatnot on it, then use the Caviar Greens for media storage, which doesn't need to be fast (unless copying everything over, but that's a one time wait)

As far as the SSD goes, the Samsung EVO is nice... don't get me wrong... Corsair, Samsung, and Intel make excellent SSDs... Corsair currently has the biggest BUS on their Force series, so I chose it as it will be a bit faster...

If you'll notice, the $4,000 Mac Pro even has 16GB of Memory... it also happens to be 1866 clock which is the sweet spot for clock and low CAS latency...  There's a few things about adding 64GB of memory if you aren't using it (and you won't in the next 5-6 years). First, it adds 4 more failure points to your system... Second, it will stress the motherboard powering all of them (especially at high density and clock speeds)... Third, the only reason you would ever use it is if you had a 4-6 monitor setup and ran virtual OS on each different monitor... then video edited while all that was running... Fourth... RAM is by far the easiest upgrade to install on a computer... pull two tabs, push... done... if you need more later, buy more...

As far as who makes good memory... I always look between Corsair, GSkill, Crucial, Samsung, Kingston, Adata, and Mushkin... whoever has the size/speed/lowest CAS/price combination I'm looking for, I'll recommend, all are quality...

About the case... if you like the Fractal case better than the Corsair (which is also a nice case) EATX isn't supported by the Define R4... the full tower version is the Define XL R2 but I don't think it comes with a window (and if you spend $4,000 on hardware I'm pretty sure you'll want to look at it) the XL R2 is a bit cheaper, however, and Fractal's cases are extremely high quality and designed very well...

If you're looking for air coolers, there's a few options... I'm a fan of Cooler Master Hyper EVO for budget, Enermax ETS-T40, any Phanteks model (depends on what size), and any Noctua model (again, depending how big you wanna get)

I don't mind overkill, but I encouriage you to not just throw gobs of money at a computer without any particular reason for it... key things to look at:

4-core Haswell i7 vs 6-core Ivy Bridge E i7

Water or Air cooled?

If you go with the Haswell i7/Z87, what expandability are you really missing out on? (also dictates case choice)

How much memory do you REALLY need? Are you running virtual OS or video processing? If no, 16GB is plenty of overkill...

How big of an SSD are you comfortable with? What programs/OS do you want on it? Get big enough to hold your core programs and operating system, maybe a little to play with, and that's all you need...

I encourage you to try ONE 780 out before you introduce SLI... they are monsters...

A lot of these decisions are based off the processor/mobo choice... but if you're multitasking/photo editing/gaming/media serving.... you aren't doing anything that needs a $4,000 system... I'm not saying don't do it... just be aware you're buying more than you'll ever use with the $2,000 build I posted (maybe you really do need that much storage, I haven't seen your media collection haha)...

I do think either build will last 5-6 years easily... hope I helped...

Thanks so much, you've really given me some things to think about which was my intended goal with this posting :p The reason I was so decided on sli was that I'm running a single evga gtz 760 in my current i5 gaming computer and it pretty much sucks, I wish I hadn't cheaped out on it and had purchased a better card. There are definitely processor bottlenecks involved too but yeah.

I will do some more research based on what you've suggested. I think I can probably reduce some of the overblown components and shave some dollars off to use elsewhere in the build. I've been saving for awhile for this though so I want to get the best set up I can even if that means spending less money lol.

Thanks so much again, I really appreciate it

I recommend you wait for Intel to release their new Haswell-E CPUs, which will only be compatible with LGA2011-3 boards(No LGA2011 support at all).  The i7-5930K is confirmed to be an 8-Core processor and should be about ~$550.

If don't care too much about that, then you should get a dual LGA2011 motherboard and two i7-4930Ks.  I also recommend that you only use SSDs for the storage and buy a NAS with a bunch of 4TB drives for all of your mass storage.

http://pcpartpicker.com/p/2LqrZ  i updated it a touch

any idea on how long it might be for those to come out? Also I don't think I can run dual cpu and stay in my budget lol.

the titan is really only useful for game developers right? From what I read there's negligible gains in fps for gaming. I considered going for 780ti's though. The prices are dropping down abit and they seem like a better deal.

The 780 in gaming made the titan almost pointless, the 780 ti in gaming makes it a complete waste. The only good thing about the titan is that is has double precision which is yes, a developer tool.