Broken Headset

So recently, my brother broke his Turtle Beach X12s. His birthday is coming up soon and I was wondering if it would be better to spend $40-60 on a new headset for him (Links: goo.gl/4S2HnN and goo.gl/rJ9Dy3) or save up for $100 and buy him a nice headset (Links: http://goo.gl/8wUhzY, http://goo.gl/lIG0nW, and http://goo.gl/ZnGrzN) or if you have any suggestions that you think would be better than then the headsets I listed, go ahead and tell me. My brother plays a lot of online games (Lots of MOBA's, SWtor, some other games that aren't worth mentioning.) Thanks in advance :D! 

Anyone?