Best way to push Asus to release BW-EP Xeon support for their X99 boards

As the title suggest, Asus has not released a bios for broadwell-ep xeon support, but only for the broadwell-e i7s.

Other AIBs like asrock and so on have support for the xeons on their x99 boards, whilst Asus is the only one who hasn't.
There is no physical limitation on their boards that keeps broadwell-ep xeons from running on their boards, only that they haven't "enabled" it.

Was really upset that my xeon only posts on the sabertooth if I reset the cmos each time I want to start it, but it works just fine in windows without any stability issues or weird behavior.

I sent a ticket to asus a month ago and all I got in response was "At this moment there is unfortuantely no Xeon V4 support on the Sabertooth X99 motherboard.
I have forwarded your request to our headquarter however I can't say if or when an update will be available."

Over on overclock.net they have an asus rep who is a pretty nice guy and could probably give you a better idea of what is going on.

The non-workstation and enterprise motherboards don't support Xeons with Asus because it would nullify the reason to have workstation and enterprise market motherboards that are more expensive than the gaming and cheap ones. It's more of a matter of financials than it is if they can or can't enable it in bios.

The consumer boards don't have ECC support along with some other features.
All X99 boards from asus support the older V3 xeons, so not supporting V4 is really weird.

Probably a shift in what they want market wise. Xeon support wasn't always supported right at launch.

I have confirmation the X99A-II and X99 Strix supports Xeon, but I haven't tested it myself yet. No ECC but the cpu is supported.

If they don't add Xeon support for the older boards when there is nothing on a hardware level that keeps them from doing so, and launch refresh x99 with Xeon V4 support I swear I'll cut someone.

That's a really garbage thing to do to your users if this is true.

1 Like

The best way to do it is to not buy their shit. Money is power. If enough boards aren't moving because of lack of a feature they will put that feature in

1 Like

Well yes indeed, it sounds a bit weird to me.
Haswell Xeon´s also worked normaly on their X99 boards.
But of course no support for ECC.

So it turns out that the new boards have the same problem reported on the Sabertooth X99, and I was able to replicate the problem on my Sabertooth X99. There is a bleeding-edge UEFI I have been asked to try. I have escalated the issue and asus HQ is going to look into it when they return to the office next week on like.. Wednesday somewhere though there.

3 Likes

Thats great news thanks. ☺
But yeah not realy sure what the actual bennefit would be from running a Xeon V4 in a X99 board.
But still.

Unless you pick something like the 2620-V4 8 cores 16 threads 2.1GHz base 3.0 turbo. for just $400,-
Thats of course a nice chip.

Thanks, so they're going to look into it instead of ignoring it to milk their new boards. Good to hear.
I was about to start taking the microcode packages from the WS board and swapping it into the sabertooth, I guess I don't have to risk it then.

can you post a photo of the lid of your cpu?

Who wants to know? Why?

1 Like

it has batch/stepping/etc info about the cpu.. it may be a bug in the microcode updates from intel, or possibly you have an early engineering sample cpu.. they are working on replicating the issue

The one I have is a ES chip.

QHV8 1.5ghz

But it isn't isolated to the ES chips, I have looked into it and sabertooth is literally missing the microcode patch for the V4 Xeon lineup.

http://www.tomshardware.co.uk/answers/id-3059744/asus-release-bios-supports-broadwell-sabertooth-x99.html
Same problem I get, only works if the CMOS is reset.

Boards from other manufacturers that support Xeon V4 have the same microcode patch as the X99WS-E (left)

Asus consumer board has the microcode patch that is on the right, no bueno Xeon V4.

Good news bad news. Good news is that I have an ES that works, but its the final/release version. Bad news its that the other ES CPUs we have are not going to be supported on Asus boards. "Sometimes Intel changes the microcode so that the newest microcode locks out the older ES steppings..." so, not probably not on purpose, but we're SOL on these boards with ES cpus.

We did try retail Xeon CPUs and they were fine.

Getting sabertooth, many regrets.

Time to start bios modding and or trading my board.

2 Likes

You might want to try supermicro boards before they lockout ES, so far I have no problem running dual xeon ES broadwell on it. I havent upgraded the bios on it yet ( Im afraid that cpus might not be supported hehe) but you might have to change ram ( if its not supported).