Best FS and RAID mode for Linux Desktops in 2024

I would discourage you from using ZFS. BTRFS is integrated into the Kernel and ZFS, because of the unique licensing, probably never will be in Linux. I lived with ZFS as a filesystem for a while but it makes trouble on a regular basis. In case you rely on precompiled binaries you always need to make sure the installed ZFS packages are compatible to the kernel and in case you use a kernel module that build automatically when you install a new kernel, you will need to fix it yourself when it does not compile and errors out one day. Definitely not a recommendation.

BTRFS does fine if you ask me, but I only ever did mirrors using it.

MDADM is high performance and rock stable, but it does not offer features like checksumming and compression on it’s own. I figure MDADM with BTRFS on top should be doable, but I have no experience with it!

2 Likes