I apologize for the length, but I have already done hours of troubleshooting and want to put as many details as I can to avoid suggestions of things I have tried.
So maybe this is the wrong sub-forum as I don't actually think the problem is with my HDD's, but something is whacky with the storage array I am trying to build. Here is the setup, I am trying to use this as both a file server and a media center so I am running Win 7 (yes I know not ideal for a file server but it works and I need the usability of the desktop)
Proc: AMD Phenom II x6 1090T
Mobo: MSI 890GXM-G65
RAM: 16GB Corsair Vengeance 1866
GPU: Visiontek LP HD 7750
PSU: Seasonic 300W Gold TFX
SSD: 128GB Samsung 830
HDD: 3x 4TB Seagate ST4000DM000
Optical: Silverstone Slim BD-R
Add-Ins: ASUS PCE-AC66 Wireless
Silverstone EC-04 USB 3.0 Card
Rosewill RC-120 SATA 150 card
Case: In-Win BL040.300TB3LF
Yes there is a ton of stuff packed into a very small space, anyway...
I have 5 internal SATA ports, 3 of these are occupied by the 4TB seagates, 1 is my system SSD, and 1 is for an external HDD dock in a 3.5 bay. I have the Rosewill card in there to add another ESATA port and to connect the BD-R drive. My goal is to RAID 5 the 4TB drives. When I set this up in the RAID BIOS on the MB this works fine, I am able to format in windows, and the drives show up as an 8TB partition. GREAT! Time to transfer my files over from my externals.
Here is where things begin to get odd. After a short time (exact amount varies, between 10 sec and 2 min I would say) either I get a blue screen with ahci64.sys showing as the issue, or the storage volume diappears and the file transfer has an error. When I reboot the RAID BIOS shows the RAID 5 as critical, However the drive that is missing is still seen by the BIOS as an individual drive. (SATA Port 3 dropped out, the 4TB drives are on ports 2,3,4)
My first thought was bad HDD, Swapped the cables between ports 2 and 3, same failure during transfer and this time it is SATA port 2 that dropped out, SUCCESS I thought, I figured it out, but I should be sure. So now I swap cables between ports 2 and 4 and try again. PORT 3 AGAIN!? WTF?? Getting a funny feeling I swap cables between port 3 and port 5 (my external drive dock) and try again. Bluescreens like normal, but this time no RAID failure. Try this 4 times with the same results, so I put the only 4TB drive to not have dropped out yet on port 3 and try again. Port 3 once again drops out. OK I tell myself, maybe a bad sata port, so I avoid it all together and plug my externals into the PCI card, ditching the optical for now.
This seems to work for somewhat longer, but eventually blue screens again with the ahci64.sys problem as usual, only still no RAID going critical. At this point I am suspecting the MOBO, conveniently I have a brand new spare on hand, I install that and am feeling confident. Wrong. Get it all set, start the file transfer, and wouldnt you know it, bluescreen sending the array critical with a dropped drive on port 3.
Right now I have the controller in AHCI mode so I can see SMART data, and am doing a full format on each drive, so far that is going well, even using port 3.
So I come to you guys for this. Is there something that could cause the SATA interface to go wonky in RAID mode, and still carry over between motherboards? The SATA controller is on the SB850 southbridge so I would expect changing the motherboard would have fixed it. I am almost certain the drives are OK at this point based on the SMART data and the fact that the format is going OK. I am fairly sure the motherboard is fine since the symptoms are identical on two boards (albeit identical model). My only real thought at this point is that the CPU is somehow the culprit, maybe a bad hypertransport link or something. It is an old and abused CPU so it would not surprise me if it was damaged somehow, but besides this odd quirk in RAID mode it seems to work fine. I can pull the CPU out of one of my other rigs, but before I tear two rigs apart I figured I would ask for help.
This has been hours and hours of stress for me at this point so I appreciate the patience to read all of that and any help anyone may offer.